Skip to main content

Shadowboxing US Brahmins? What's wrong with critique of 'The Economist' article

By Atticus Finch*
Rajesh Chavda’s recent rebuttal in “The Wire”, Brahmins Claim to Be Victims of Affirmative Action: This 'Untouchable' Lawyer Begs to Differ, to the “Economist” piece Why Brahmins lead Western firms but rarely Indian ones is at once an exercise in Kabuki Theatre -- a back and forth of strawman shadowboxing.
Chavda’s beef is the admittedly conservative magazine’s support of the "laughable suggestion… in the absence of any data in support”. He laments "conspicuously absent” data or research, leading to “speculation” in support of its arguments.
This is strange. “The Economist” article actually puts down incontrovertible easily verifiable public data from -- first 20, then 1,000, and ends up number-crunching 1,530 listed companies in 2021 in support of its premise that (by numbers in India) it’s non-Brahmin classes that dominate board rooms in contrast with Indian-origin CEOs of seven top US companies, all upper-caste.
Chavda, on the other hand, adduces 12-year old data across a much smaller 57 companies’ set, coming across freshman-like as he tries to prove the counter. Still, it is worth considering the more important converse hypothesis that Chavda actually seeks to takedown from the original article’s assertion, "Affirmative action in India has pushed them [Brahmins] away, too” [middle, last but one para in “The Economist”].
“The Economist” indeed does a poor job of securing its claim, hand-waving in the anecdote of Kamala Harris’ mother going to the US for graduate studies in the 1950s. Where Chavda fails, however, in his piece, is when he merely highlights a disproportionate presence of Brahmins in his own 1995 batch of National Law School of India University or NLS cohorts. The argument is not dispositive that Brahmins have not been the victims of discrimination due to reservations.
Chavda’s argument, in fact, is something straight out of the Journal of Anecdotal Science. Instead of attempting to show that there were no admissible Brahmins (north of public open-seats' cutoffs) left unenrolled that year which -- had he chosen to prove -- would have justifiably supported his claim, he adduces data demonstrating the exact opposite!
In his 1995 cohort of NLS entrants, fewer than reserved seats by set-aside quotas were secured by claimants from the “reserved communities”, hence more Brahmins -- by his own admission -- took those places. Importantly, he fails to demonstrate that no Brahmins who would have been admitted as per the defined NLS cutoffs. They would have been left seatless in the presence of a reservation-framework.
Thus, in attempting to prove a contra-positive, he does more harm than good in favour of compensatory discrimination regimes such as what India and the US have come to adopt. Had he stuck to a more dispassionate title such as “Suck it up, the country as a whole has benefited”, much like the underlying theme of a compelling recent piece from Tamil Nadu minister P Thiagarajan, it might have even been persuasive.
In the US, such policies are being litigated, a growing recognition that in the absence reparatory of social justice amendments, any compensatory discrimination policies are necessarily unconstitutional -- given usual higher commitments against racial discrimination. As a solicitor, it’s disappointing that Chavda does not argue well.
---  
*Pseudonym of a software technology management professional

Comments

TRENDING

Adani coalmine delayed? Australian senate fails to pass crucial "reform" amendment for project's financial closure

Adanis' Mundra power plant, controversial in Australia By  A  Representative In what is being described as a new “new hurdle”, the proposed Adani coalmine in the Queensland state of in Australia failed to get the crucial Australian Parliamentary nod, essential for financial closure for one of the biggest coalmining projects in the world. The government lost the Senate vote 35-33, meaning the legislation won't pass until the Senate returns in mid-June.

Aurangzeb’s last will recorded by his Maulvi: Allah shouldn't make anyone emperor

By Mohan Guruswamy  Aurangzeb’s grave is a simple slab open to the sky lying along the roadside at Khuldabad near Aurangabad. I once stopped by to marvel at the tomb of an Emperor of India whose empire was as large as Ashoka the Great's. It was only post 1857 when Victoria's domain exceeded this. The epitaph reads: "Az tila o nuqreh gar saazand gumbad aghniyaa! Bar mazaar e ghareebaan gumbad e gardun bas ast." (The rich may well construct domes of gold and silver on their graves. For the poor folks like me, the sky is enough to shelter my grave) The modest tomb of Aurangzeb is perhaps the least recognised legacies of the Mughal Emperor who ruled the land for fifty eventful years. He was not a builder having expended his long tenure in war and conquest. Towards the end of his reign and life, he realised the futility of it all. He wrote: "Allah should not make anyone an emperor. The most unfortunate person is he who becomes one." Aurangzeb’s last will was re...

Paul Newman wasn't just remarkably talented, he was anti-war activist, disdained Hollywood excesses

By Harsh Thakor*  On January 26th of this year, we celebrated the birth centenary of Paul Newman, one of the finest actors of his era. His passing on September 26, 2008, after a prolonged battle with lung cancer, was met with an outpouring of tributes and remembrances from artists across the film industry, all sharing their thoughts and memories of the legendary actor.  

Beyond his riding skill, Karl Umrigar was admired for his radiance, sportsmanship, and affability

By Harsh Thakor*  Karl Umrigar's name remains etched in the annals of Indian horse racing, a testament to a talent tragically cut short. An accident on the racetrack at the tender age of nineteen robbed India of a rider on the cusp of greatness. Had he survived, there's little doubt he would have ascended to international stature, possibly becoming the greatest Indian jockey ever. Even 46 years after his death, his name shines brightly, reminiscent of an inextinguishable star. His cousin, Pesi Shroff, himself blossomed into one of the most celebrated jockeys in Indian horse racing.

Haven't done a good deed, inner soul is cursing me as sinner: Aurangzeb's last 'will'

Counterview Desk The Tomb of Aurangzeb, the last of the strong Mughal emperors, located in Khuldabad, Aurangabad district, Maharashtra, has this epitaph inscribed on it: "Az tila o nuqreh gar saazand gumbad aghniyaa! Bar mazaar e maa ghareebaan gumbad e gardun bas ast" (the rich may well construct domes of gold and silver on their graves. For the poor folks like me, the sky is enough to shelter my grave).

Hyderabad seminar rekindles memories of the spark lit 50 years ago by students

By Harsh Thakor*  History is something we constantly remember and reflect upon, but certain moments and events bring it back to our memory in a special way. For the Telugu people, and Telangana in particular, the memorial seminar held on February 20–21 was a significant occasion to recall the glorious events, transformations, leaders, and heroes of past struggles. Thousands of students rewrote the history of people's movements in Andhra Pradesh, carrying revolutionary zeal and the spirit of self-sacrifice to levels comparable to the Russian and Chinese Revolutions.

Trust, we (from People to PM and President) did not take a Holy Dip in some Holy Shit!

By Dr Mansee Bal Bhargava  I could see two deeply interlinked aspects between human and water in #MahaKumbh2025. Firstly, the HOPE that a ‘holy dip’ in the River Ganga (colloquially referred as dubki and spiritually as ‘Snan’) will cleanse oneself (especially the sins); and secondly, the TRUST that the water is pure to perform the cleansing alias living the hope. Well, I consider hope to be self-dependent while, trust is a multi-party dependent situation. The focus here is on the trust and I shall write later on hope.

Vadodara citizens urge authorities to adhere to environmental mandates in Vishwamitri River Rejuvenation Project

By A Representative   A coalition of environmental activists, ecologists, and urban planners in Vadodara has issued an urgent appeal to state and municipal authorities, demanding strict compliance with court-mandated guidelines for the upcoming Vishwamitri River rejuvenation project. Scheduled to commence in March 2025, the initiative aims to mitigate flooding and restore the river, but citizens warn that current plans risk violating National Green Tribunal (NGT) orders and jeopardizing the river’s fragile ecosystem, home to endangered species like crocodiles and Indian Softshell Turtles.  

Buddhist communities in Michigan protest for Mahabodhi Temple’s return to Buddhist control

By A Representative   Buddhist communities in Michigan have staged protests demanding the return of the Mahabodhi Vihara in Gaya, Bihar, India, to full Buddhist control. The Mahabodhi Temple, regarded as the holiest pilgrimage site in Buddhism, is currently managed under the Bodhgaya Temple Act of 1949, which grants a majority of control to non-Buddhists.

A Communist leader, an advocate for unity, against opportunism and sectarianism

By Harsh Thakor*  Dhurva Narayan, a prominent leader from Bihar and a Central Committee member of the former PCC, CPI (ML) as well as the newly merged CPI (ML)-MassLine, passed away on February 12, 2025. He was an influential figure in the Indian Communist revolutionary movement for over five decades, known for his role in opposing Hindutva politics and globalization. Narayan was committed to fostering unity within Communist ranks and advocating against opportunism and sectarianism.