Valid concern? India's food security, hunger data remain undisclosed, for 'internal' use

By Nandlal Mishra*
In a recent article published in the “Indian Express” on July 7, 2023, Shamika Ravi brings attention to the valid concern of assessing the data quality of large-scale national surveys such as National Sample Survey (NSS), Periodic Labour Force Survey (PLFS) and National Family Health Survey (NFHS). While her argument raises important points, the example she chooses to support her argument is flawed. It is essential to address this misconception and highlight the actual limitations of sample surveys.
Ravi states that major surveys conducted in India post-2011, which utilized the 2011 census as the sampling frame, have significantly overestimated the proportion of the rural population. However, this argument overlooks the fundamental constraint of sample surveys that to select representative rural and urban populations these surveys rely on the most recent census data available to identify areas as either rural or urban. Due to resource and time limitations, it is not feasible for surveys to independently define an area as rural or urban. Hence, they rely on existing census data for this purpose.
The classification of an area as rural or urban is the responsibility of the Office of the Registrar General of India (RGI), not the survey organizers. Therefore, if an area was defined as rural in the 2011 census, it would be considered rural in all subsequent surveys, till next census data is available, even if it meets the criteria to be classified as urban during that time.
Considering that the proportion of rural population in the 2011 census was 69 per cent, the share of rural population in these sample surveys should ideally be around 69 per cent. In reality, the estimates for the rural population in these surveys conducted during last decade are quite accurate, with only a small overestimation of 1 to 2 percent in exceptional cases. This overestimation can be attributed to lower response rates in urban areas across all these surveys. Thus, the slight overestimation is a result of non-response in urban areas, presenting a new challenge for data producers.

Furthermore, Ravi compares these survey estimates with the projected rural population figures of different years provided by the RGI Expert Committee. However, comparing these estimates with survey data based on the sampling frames obtained from the 2011 census, which are supposed to align with the census figures regardless of the year of the survey, is not a fair comparison. Therefore, the example chosen by Ravi is not reflective of data quality issues but rather the inherent limitations of surveys relying on census data for defining rural and urban areas.

Estimates for rural population in these surveys are quite accurate, with only a small overestimation of 1 to 2 percent in exceptional cases

Now, let’s address the chart provided alongside the article. The first two surveys (NSS 68th round) mentioned in the chart were designed and carried out in 2011-12, prior to the release of the census data from 2011. These surveys relied on sampling frames obtained from the census conducted in 2001, resulting in an estimation of the rural population by over 71 per cent. Furthermore, chart itself was distorted, failing to represent equal distances on the x-axis with equal intervals. It is crucial to present data accurately and meaningfully, as incorrect visualizations can lead to misleading interpretations.

Instead of focusing on examples prone to default errors, Ravi could have chosen indicators such as dependency ratio, sex ratio, literacy rate, households with access to electricity, improved water, and improved sanitation facilities. These indicators are less susceptible to inbuilt errors and would have provided a more accurate representation of data quality concerns.
Moving forward, it is imperative for the government to expedite the conduct of the 2021 census. This will ensure the availability of an updated sampling frame for sample surveys, leading to more accurate estimates, including the proportions of urban and rural populations. An updated census will address the limitations associated with using outdated data, enabling survey organizers to accurately define areas as rural or urban based on current circumstances.
Ravi raises a valid concern regarding transparency in data. An example of this is the 78th round of NSS conducted in 2020-21, which collected data on food security and hunger but has not been released to the public. The report states that this data was collected for internal use, leaving readers perplexed as to why it remains undisclosed.

Releasing the hunger data would enable a better assessment of claims made by global hunger indices and other surveys regarding the hunger and malnutrition crisis in the country. Transparency in data release is crucial for fostering trust in the survey process and facilitating informed policy decisions.
---
*Doctoral fellow at International Institute for Population Sciences, Mumbai

Comments

राजस्थान, मध्यप्रदेश, पश्चिम बंगाल, झारखंड और केरल फिसड्डी: जल जीवन मिशन के लक्ष्य को पाने समन्वित प्रयास जरूरी

- राज कुमार सिन्हा* जल संसाधन से जुड़ी स्थायी समिति ने वर्तमान लोकसभा सत्र में पेश रिपोर्ट में बताया है कि "नल से जल" मिशन में राजस्थान, मध्यप्रदेश, पश्चिम बंगाल, झारखंड और केरल फिसड्डी साबित हुए हैं। जबकि देश के 11 राज्यों में शत-प्रतिशत ग्रामीणों को नल से जल आपूर्ति शुरू कर दी गई है। रिपोर्ट में समिति ने केंद्र सरकार को सिफारिश की है कि मिशन पुरा करने में राज्य सरकारों की समस्याओं पर गौर किया जाए।

'A tribal lifeline': Health rights group asks Gujarat governor to halt Vyara govt hospital privatization

By A Representative In a strong appeal to the Governor of Gujarat, the National Health Rights Alliance (NHRA)—an initiative of the National Alliance of People's Movements (NAPM)—has urged the state to halt the ongoing move to privatize the Vyara Government Hospital and Medical College in Tapi district.

Old bias, new excuses: How western media misrepresents India’s anti-terror strikes

By Gajanan Khergamker The recent Indian military strikes on Pakistan, dubbed Operation Sindoor, have sparked a storm of international media coverage. Several prominent outlets have portrayed India as the aggressor in the escalating conflict, raising concerns over biased reporting. This commentary critiques coverage by foreign media outlets such as The New York Times , Reuters, BBC, and CNN, which have often been accused of framing India’s actions as escalatory while downplaying or omitting critical context regarding Pakistan’s role in fostering terrorism. By examining historical patterns and current geopolitical dynamics, this analysis highlights the recurring selective framing, omission of evidence, and a tendency to favor narratives aligned with Western geopolitical interests over factual nuance.

जैविक जीवित संसाधनों व प्रकृति पर निर्भर मजदूरों की व्यापक आर्थिक सुरक्षा कैसे हो?

- राज कुमार सिन्हा* भारत में 60 करोड़ से अधिक लोग भूमि, जल, जंगल और समुद्र जैसे प्राकृतिक स्रोतों पर निर्भर हैं । देश में 14.6 करोड़ छोटे और सीमांत किसान, 14.4 करोड़ खेतिहर मजदूर ( बड़ी संख्या में दलित हैं), 27.5 करोड़ वन निवासी, 2.8 करोड़ मछुआरे, 1.3 करोड़ पशुपालक और 1.7 करोड़ कारीगर हैं जो सीधे तौर पर प्रकृति के साथ और प्रकृति के भरोसे काम कर रहे हैं । लगभग 6 करोड़ मौसमी मजदूर हैं जो काम के सिलसिले में लगातार अपने गांव से बाहर जाते हैं और लौटते हैं। प्रकृति निर्भर समुदायों की आर्थिक गतिविधियां जो बड़े पैमाने पर जीवन निर्वाह और छोटी आय के लिए है। वर्तमान आर्थिक नीतियों के कारण, जो कॉर्पोरेट्स और बड़े व्यवसायों का समर्थन करती है, प्रकृति निर्भर समुदाय के लिए अव्यवहारिक होती जा रही है।

Censor Board's bullying delays 'Phule': A blow to India's democratic spirit

By Vidya Bhushan Rawat* A film based on the life and legacy of Jyotiba Phule and Savitribai Phule was expected to release today. Instead, its release has been pushed to the last week of April. The reason? Protests by self-proclaimed guardians of caste pride—certain Brahmin groups—and forced edits demanded by a thoroughly discredited Censor Board.

CASR urges immediate halt to Operation Kagaar, calls for peace talks with Maoists

By A Representative The Campaign Against State Repression (CASR), a collective of over 40 civil society organizations, has issued a press statement demanding an immediate end to "Operation Kagaar" and alleged state-led killings of Maoist rebels and indigenous people in central India. The group also called on the central government to create a conducive environment for initiating peace talks with the banned Communist Party of India (Maoist).

Naveen Gautam creates history, becomes first Dalit youth to moderate session at UN

By A Representative In a historic moment for Communities Discriminated on Work and Descent, Mr. Naveen Gautam of the Global Forum of Communities Discriminated on Work and Descent (GFoD) became the first Dalit youth to moderate a session at any United Nations forum.

Kashmiriyat lives: Beyond the prime-time lies

By Rimmi Vaghela I am Rimmi from Ahmedabad. I contemplated this blog on April 27, 2025 in Jammu, when my plans of revisiting the paradise called Kashmir were shattered—not by fear, but by circumstances and sorrow. I decided to share my story with a heavy heart, hoping it reaches those who still believe in the warmth of humanity over the divisive noise of prime-time media.

Choice of the word 'Sindoor' in India's anti-terror operation: Symbolic feminism or patriarchal strategy?

By Dr. Mansee Bal Bhargava* In the aftermath of a war and subsequent ceasefire in 2025, Operation Sindoor has emerged as a focal point of national discourse, not only for its military objectives but also for its symbolic framing. The operation, named after a traditional marker of Hindu marital identity, and the prominent roles of Colonel Sofiya Qureshi of the Indian Army and Wing Commander Vyomika Singh of the Indian Air Force in its media briefings, have been widely celebrated as a step toward gender inclusivity.

In the fury of war, humanity succumbs to the illusion of nationalism

By Dr. Mansee Bal Bhargava* On May 7, Rabindranath Tagore Jayanti—also known as Rabindra Jayanti or Poncheeshe Boishakh in Kolkata—we celebrated the birth anniversary of the renowned poet, writer, philosopher, reformer, and Nobel laureate. On this occasion, I draw attention to Tagore’s timeless quotes, which resonate profoundly today, perhaps more than ever, as we live in a time when the ruling government has pushed the nation toward war.

Search This Blog