Gandhi wasn't a man of jumlas, or Union Home Minister Amit Shah's electoral promise

By Rosamma Thomas*

In November 2023, in a speech at Bucharest, Romania, Belgian clinical psychologist Dr Mattias Desmet alluded to the power of Mahatma Gandhi, and his weapon of non-violent resistance. He explained that Gandhi considered “sincere speech” to be the core and essence of non-violent resistance.

Desmet explains that in Gandhi’s autobiography, he mentions that he was not a man of talent – he was not handsome or physically strong, not intelligent at school, not a good writer, not a good speaker – but he had a passion for sincere speech, and his autobiography is titled “My Experiments with Truth” (Desmet’s full speech can be accessed in the video embedded here).

Union Home Minister Amit Shah stands in sharp contrast to that ideal; explaining away a promise Narendra Modi made in November 2013 to fetch back all the black money stashed abroad so that Rs 15 lakh could be transferred to the accounts of all Indians, Shah said it was mere “jumla” – just an election promise that the speaker and his audience, both know, cannot be. For Shah, making such statements was the normal thing to do while seeking votes.

“Ram Nam Satya Hai” is chanted during the last rites among Hindus – the name of Ram is truth; and it comforts and endures, remaining unchanging and permanent. Gandhi, taking the assassin’s bullets, had the name of Ram on his lips. The Union Home Minister, however, finds clever ways to justify misleading words.

When Opposition members in Lok Sabha pointed out, during the debate on the Jammu and Kashmir Reorganization Bill and the Jammu and Kashmir Reservation (Amendment) Bill that abrogation of Article 370 of the Constitution had not put an end to terrorism as earlier stated, the Home Minister said he had never claimed any such thing – "The Hindu" reported that he said only that a “zero-terror” plan had been formulated and would be implemented. Plans do not always work as anticipated, and the people of India better understand that, was what Shah appeared to state in the news report carried on page 1 of the newspaper on December 7, 2023.

That very day, another news item on the inside pages of the paper was noteworthy – the Union government told Parliament that the Char Dham project of which the Silkyara tunnel in Uttarakhand was a part, did not require Environment Impact Assessment.

A notification of August 22, 2013 from the Union Ministry of Environment and Forests had stated that an expansion of National Highways by more than 100 km involving right of way or land acquisition of more than 40 metres on existing alignments and 60 metres on realignments required prior environmental clearance.

The Char Dham project totals 825 km in length, but was being developed in parcels of 53 projects, each measuring less than 100 km. There was thus no need for a clearance, according to the response in the Rajya Sabha from Nitish Gadkari, Union road transport minister.

It appears not to matter to the Union government that such brazen distortion of the provisions of law puts lives at risk. The 41 workers trapped inside the Silkyara tunnel when a section gave way were rescued after 17 harrowing days, but about 130 visitors at Morbi bridge in Gujarat in October 2022, which collapsed soon after a problematic “renovation” was completed, were not fortunate enough to survive.

In 2022, journalist Niranjan Takle published his account of an investigation that in any democracy would have ended political careers. "Who Killed Judge Loya?" is the title of the book, but readers will not be left with any doubt once they turn the last page of the book.

From Niranjan Takle's book

On December 1, 2014, Judge Brijgopal Harkishan Loya, presiding judge of the CBI special court hearing the case of the alleged involvement of Amit Shah in the 2005 murders of Sohrabuddin Sheikh and his wife Kausarbi, died mysteriously. Shah had been jailed in connection with these murders in 2010.

By December 30, 2014, the new judge, MB Gosavi, discharged Shah and ruled that the allegations were politically motivated. “When a trial that involves over a hundred witnesses, a charge-sheet greater than 10,000 pages, and hundreds of call data records concludes within 48 hours, then even toddlers can foresee the upcoming verdict…” writes Niranjan Takle.

But then, what are such foibles, when compared to the lack of ethics of former MP Mahua Moitra?

---
*Freelance journalist

Comments

Hyderabad protest demands end to Operation Kagar as senior Maoist leaders killed in encounter

By Harsh Thakor* A protest was held on June 17 at Indira Park in Hyderabad by the Shanti Charchala Committee, calling for an end to Operation Kagar and the start of peace talks with Maoist groups. The event brought together representatives from several political parties and civil society organizations. Among those who addressed the gathering were CPI (ML) New Democracy Central Committee member Vemulapalli Venkatramayya, along with leaders from the Congress, BRS, CPI, CPM, Telangana Janasamithi, MCPI, SUCI, CPI ML, RSP, and VCK. The programme also featured performances by cultural groups such as CLC, HRF, TVV, Arunodaya, Praja Kala Mandali, and Praja Natya Mandali. Public figures including actors Narayana Murthy and Tudundebba Upendar and academics like Professor Anver Khan and Professor Vinayaka Reddy participated as speakers.

Food security crisis persists in Gujarat despite NFSA: Survey reveals grim ground reality

By A Representative A new field-based survey conducted in January 2025 across Dahod, Panchmahals, Morbi, and Bhavnagar districts has revealed alarming levels of food insecurity among vulnerable communities in Gujarat, ten years after the implementation of the National Food Security Act (NFSA). Conducted by Anandi – Area Networking and Development Initiatives (ASAA) and community organisations working with mahila sangathans, the Gujarat Food Security Survey covered 1,261 households, purposively chosen to reflect the experiences of marginalised populations including Adivasis, OBCs, single women, the disabled, and the elderly. The findings suggest that despite the promises of NFSA and wide coverage under the Public Distribution System (PDS), food deprivation remains widespread and systemic failures continue to exclude the most vulnerable.

Land under siege: A silent crisis, desertification is threatening India’s future

By Raj Kumar Sinha* Desertification is emerging as one of the gravest environmental challenges of our time. Marked annually on June 17, the World Day to Combat Desertification and Drought reminds us that the fate of our planet’s land—and the billions who depend on it—is hanging in the balance.

Victim to cricketing politics, Alvin Kalicharan was a most organized left handed batsman

By Harsh Thakor* On March 21st Alvin Kalicharan celebrates his 75th birthday. Sadly, his exploits have been forgotten or overlooked. Arguably no left handed batsman was technically sounder or more organized than this little man. Kalicharan was classed as a left-handed version of Rohan Kanhai. Possibly no left-handed batsmen to such a degree blend technical perfection with artistry and power.

Central London discussion to spotlight LGBTQ+ ex-Muslim rights and persecution

By A Representative On June 13, 2025, the Dissident Club in Central London will host a public discussion to mark the 18th anniversary of the Council of Ex-Muslims of Britain (CEMB) and to commemorate World Refugee Day. The event, scheduled from 7:00 to 9:00 pm, will feature speakers Ali Malik, Maryam Namazie, and Taha Siddiqui, who are expected to address the intersecting challenges faced by LGBTQ+ ex-Muslims globally.

Better halves lead the way as organic farmers, entrepreneurs and social reformers

By Bharat Dogra Two major challenges continue to limit the full participation of rural women in development. First, their crucial roles, potential, and capabilities often remain underrecognized. Second, even when women are encouraged to take on broader responsibilities, the overarching development models may not align with their needs or perspectives and may even appear counterproductive. Under such conditions, it is unrealistic to expect women to engage as enthusiastic and creative participants.

Lepa Radić: A symbol of defiance and resistance, of fight against oppression

By Harsh Thakor* December 29th marks the centenary of the birth of Lepa Radić, a Yugoslav Partisan whose courage during World War II continues to resonate through history. Born on December 19, 1925, in the village of Gašnica in what is now Bosnia-Herzegovina, Lepa Radić was only 15 when the Axis powers invaded Yugoslavia in April 1941. In response to the occupation, she joined the Partisan resistance, eventually becoming one of its most revered figures. At the age of 17, she was executed by the Nazis for her involvement, refusing until her death to betray her comrades.

Hope from the Amazon: Land rights, indigenous voices, and the winds of change in Latin America

By Vidya Bhushan Rawat* After several days of travel and digital silence, I returned from a rare and deeply moving journey into the Amazon region of Colombia. It was not just another field trip, but an opportunity to witness the pulse of Latin America’s land rights movement, firsthand.

Violent evictions in Nagarahole: Forest department razes adivasi huts despite FRA protections

By A Representative In a disturbing escalation of tensions between state authorities and Adivasi communities in the Nagarahole forests, over 250 personnel from the Forest Department, Special Tiger Protection Force, and local police violently demolished six huts belonging to Jenu Kuruba Adivasi families in Karadikallu Atturu Koli Haadi on June 18. The demolition took place in the midst of heavy monsoon rains, leaving families exposed to the elements and stripped of their temporary homes.

Search This Blog