Skip to main content

An insecure system? Connected with VVPAT, EVM 'no more' standalone or rudimentary

By Rosamma Thomas* 

“VVPAT machine is totally opaque,” messaged one voter who voted in Kanniyakumari constituency on April 19, when polling began for the Lok Sabha elections. The Supreme Court has issued notice to the Election Commission, on a petition seeking the counting of all Voter Verified Paper Audit Trail slips cast in the 2024 elections, instead of only verifying five randomly selected Electronic Voting Machines in each assembly segment of a parliamentary constituency.
What if the petitioner wins this case and all VVPAT slips are indeed counted. Would that suffice to ensure that the voting process has been free and fair, and that the votes have been counted accurately?
What, one might ask, is the need for a black glass atop the machine through which the voter verifies whether the vote has been cast correctly? Why cannot that glass remain transparent, as was originally the case? Why cannot the light that glows within the machine stay on until the voter actually sees the slip marking his vote fall into the box?
If members of one family all arrive at the same time at the booth and cast their votes for an Opposition candidate, might the machine be engineered to retain one slip and show the same slip to all members of the family? In that case, all votes from that family could be counted as just one.
How can a voter be absolutely sure that the slip has indeed fallen into the box? Or that the slip that he or she has seen is not the same one that emerged when the voter who stood ahead in line cast a vote?
The revelation about Professor Rajat Moona, director of the Gandhinagar IIT, who besides being among the “inventors” of the VVPAT (Voter Verifiable Paper Audit Trail) machine, also serves on the technical expert committee of the Election Commission to assess the machines, should cause heightened anxiety to Indian voters. Prof Moona is the designer of the “pardah” on the EVM machine, the prismatic lens.
Serious conflict of interest exists, in being expected to assess what one has invented. News reports earlier showed that people meant to serve as independent directors of Bharat Electronics Limited (BEL), which supplies EVM machines, were affiliated to the BJP.
In his article on The India Forum website in 2021, Kannan Gopinathan, who resigned from the Indian Administrative Service to be able to speak freely on politics, explained that the original Electronic Voting Machine was not quite the same creature that emerged after the introduction of the VVPAT system.
The earlier system was secured by the fact that the EVM was not talking to other devices, it was a standalone device -- it also had no way of connecting the candidate to the sequence in which his or her name appeared, preventing pre-programmed manipulation.
As Gopinathan explains:
“If the EVM cannot electronically know, either at the time of programming or at the time of activation, as to who is Candidate 1 and who is Candidate 2, it cannot intelligently transfer votes in favour of one from the other. It can blindly do so from 1 to 2, but that would serve no purpose as there is no way to know who Candidate 1 is and who Candidate 2 is until the candidate list has been finalized, published in Form7A and pasted on the BU (ballot unit)”.
EVMs were also randomly assigned to constituencies and then to polling stations -- a two-stage randomization that would make manipulation hard, given that it was hard to know which machine would be used where. Three-stage mock polls were held, where political party representatives could cast votes and verify results.
It was during the 2019 Lok Sabha elections that VVPAT was used for the first time, and Gopinathan was part of the team of bureaucrats trained to oversee the elections. It occurred to him then that if the machine would print the slip showing which candidate received the vote, it could not be innocent of the information about which party was represented by which sequence number.
Gopinathan was told that staff of Bharat Electronics Limited or Electronics Corporation of India Limited -- the two public sector units manufacturing the EVMs -- would “upload the sequence, names of symbols of candidates to the VVPAT as part of the commissioning process”. It became clear that for this uploading process, VVPATs would have to be connected to an external device.
The diagram and explanation that Gopinathan offered in his article are worth recalling:
The Ballot Unit-VVPAT-Control Unit Design
“As currently implemented, the VVPAT sits right in between the BU and CU and is connected to both... This essentially means the vote flow is from the BU to the VVPAT and then from the VVPAT to the CU. The vote is now being cast in the CU by the VVPAT and not directly by the BU. Such a compromised design was possibly adopted to ensure the use of the existing BUs and CUs -- some kind of a jugaad. But this introduced a serious vulnerability into the integrity of the election process. 
"There is now a programmable device in between the voter casting a vote and the CU recording that vote, thus potentially introducing a vulnerability. A key principle of the election process is ‘Cast as intended, recorded as cast and counted as recorded'. Any vulnerability in the VVPAT is now a vulnerability in the entire electronic voting process. This design flaw, in my opinion, is serious enough that we should discard the current design for this reason alone.”
The former bureaucrat points out: 
“We also need to be aware of the fact that we have to connect each VVPAT to an external device for every constituency before every election, and this has to be done after the candidate sequence is finalized and the names of the candidates and the symbols are mapped to the BU buttons.”
Names and symbols will vary across constituencies, and so there is need for a programmable memory in the VVPAT. To activate the light and the printer unit, the system needs sophistication and is not a rudimentary device. The EVM, thus, is neither standalone nor rudimentary, and the safeguards that made for a secure system earlier no longer hold, with the introduction of VVPAT.
The laptops used by technical staff of the ECIL or BEL are not supervised by election officers, and even the technical staff may not be fully aware of all that has gone into the laptop or been transferred to the symbol loading unit (SLU) or VVPAT.
Gopinathan writes: 
“To put it in other words, there is no way the district election officials can know or verify what has been transferred between the VVPAT and SLU/Laptop. Once you provide physical access of the EVM to an external device, it does not matter whether there is armed security or there are CCTVs guarding the strong room for the rest of the time. The new process thus surrenders the erstwhile physical security argument.”
The voter can only passively verify the accuracy of the vote, and there is little recourse for someone dissatisfied. If a voter complains, a test vote may be generated – but if the printing occurs accurately during the test vote, the voter may be fined or penalized. The test vote too is rather restricted, as it only checks if the next vote too is similarly manipulated.
Given these concerns, there is the real possibility that even a full count of all VVPATs may not accurately reflect the will of the people of India. What then, could be the solution, given that the election process is currently ongoing?
Two suggestions: 1. Ensure that the glass on the VVPAT machine is transparent, and voters can clearly see the symbol on the printed slip; 2. ensure that the light stays on, so voters can actually see the printed slip fall into the box after the vote is cast, and be absolutely sure that they are not shown what the voter just ahead of them cast. If such measures are put in place, perhaps a full count of VVPATs will reveal what India’s voters truly VVPAT-- a change of government, or another term for Narendra Modi.
Judges hearing the matter in the SC said they could not issue a mandamus on the basis of a suspicion – eternal vigilance, the judges might remember, is the price of freedom. Distrust is of essence, when it comes to securing liberty. The judges refused to order that the source code of the EVMs be made public, citing security concerns.
In 1990, however, the Technical Expert Committee of the Election Commission had recommended that this code be released to the public. In the past 10 years, ever since Modi became PM, no reports of the TEC are available. It is also unclear how often this committee has met in that time.
---
*Freelance journalist 

Comments

TRENDING

Loktantra Bachao Abhiyan raises concerns over Jharkhand Adivasis' plight in Assam, BJP policies

By Our Representative  The Loktantra Bachao Abhiyan (Save Democracy Campaign) has issued a pressing call to protect Adivasi rights in Jharkhand, highlighting serious concerns over the treatment of Jharkhandi Adivasis in Assam. During a press conference in Ranchi on November 9, representatives from Assam, Chhattisgarh, and Madhya Pradesh criticized the current approach of BJP-led governments in these states, arguing it has exacerbated Adivasi struggles for rights, land, and cultural preservation.

Promoting love or instilling hate and fear: Why is RSS seeking a meeting with Rahul Gandhi?

By Ram Puniyani*  India's anti-colonial struggle was marked by a diverse range of social movements, one of the most significant being Hindu-Muslim unity and the emergence of a unified Indian identity among people of all religions. The nationalist, anti-colonial movement championed this unity, best embodied by Mahatma Gandhi, who ultimately gave his life for this cause. Gandhi once wrote, “The union that we want is not a patched-up thing but a union of hearts... Swaraj (self-rule) for India must be an impossible dream without an indissoluble union between the Hindus and Muslims of India. It must not be a mere truce... It must be a partnership between equals, each respecting the religion of the other.”

A Marxist intellectual who dwelt into complex areas of the Indian socio-political landscape

By Harsh Thakor*  Professor Manoranjan Mohanty has been a dedicated advocate for human rights over five decades. His work as a scholar and activist has supported revolutionary democratic movements, navigating complex areas of the Indian socio-political landscape. His balanced, non-partisan approach to human rights and social justice has made his books essential resources for advocates of democracy.

Four J&K MLAs visit Wular lake, pledge support to fisher community, environmental conservation

By Shamim Ahmed*   In a historic meeting that highlighted both environmental and social concerns, four Members of the Legislative Assembly (MLAs) visited Wular Lake to meet with the fisherfolk community, signaling a significant step in addressing their longstanding issues. This gathering, organized with the support of dedicated advocates, marks a strengthening of efforts to both safeguard the lake’s ecosystem and support the community’s welfare.

Supreme Court’s dismissal of PIL on Covid vaccine safety is counter to known science and mathematics

By Bhaskaran Raman*  On 14 Oct 2024, the Supreme Court of India dismissed a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) on the side-effects of the Covid vaccine. In 2021, the world saw the rollout of various Covid vaccine candidates. In India, Bharat Biotech’s Covaxin and Serum Institute of India’s Covishield were rolled out. Covishield was nothing but Oxford’s AstraZeneca relabelled in India. The importance of open-minded and scientific probe of Covid vaccine safety In 2020/2021, all Covid vaccines were authorized for emergency use, which meant that the necessary efficacy and safety follow-up was incomplete at that time. The originally approved trials – called randomised controlled trials (RCT) had a “vaccine” group and a “placebo” group for comparison. Such experimental comparison/control is the cornerstone of the scientific method – which even children learn in photosynthesis experiments in class-1. The vaccine trials were scheduled to conclude in late 2022/early 2023. For instance, Covax...

Swami Vivekananda's views on caste and sexuality were 'painfully' regressive

By Bhaskar Sur* Swami Vivekananda now belongs more to the modern Hindu mythology than reality. It makes a daunting job to discover the real human being who knew unemployment, humiliation of losing a teaching job for 'incompetence', longed in vain for the bliss of a happy conjugal life only to suffer the consequent frustration.

A Hindu alternative to Valentine's Day? 'Shiv-Parvati was first love marriage in Universe'

By Rajiv Shah  The other day, I was searching on Google a quote on Maha Shivratri which I wanted to send to someone, a confirmed Shiv Bhakt, quite close to me -- with an underlying message to act positively instead of being negative. On top of the search, I chanced upon an article in, imagine!, a Nashik Corporation site which offered me something very unusual. 

Buddhist shrines were 'massively destroyed' by Brahmanical rulers: Historian DN Jha

Nalanda mahavihara By Our Representative Prominent historian DN Jha, an expert in India's ancient and medieval past, in his new book , "Against the Grain: Notes on Identity, Intolerance and History", in a sharp critique of "Hindutva ideologues", who look at the ancient period of Indian history as "a golden age marked by social harmony, devoid of any religious violence", has said, "Demolition and desecration of rival religious establishments, and the appropriation of their idols, was not uncommon in India before the advent of Islam".

Right-arm fast bowler who helped West Indies shape arguably greatest Test team in cricket history

By Harsh Thakor*  Malcolm Marshall redefined what it meant to be a right-arm fast bowler, challenging the traditional laws of biomechanics with his unique skill. As we remember his 25th death anniversary on November 4th, we reflect on the legacy he left behind after his untimely death from colon cancer. For a significant part of his career, Marshall was considered one of the fastest and most formidable bowlers in the world, helping to shape the West Indies into arguably the greatest Test team in cricket history.

Will Left victory in Sri Lanka deliver economic sovereignty plan, go beyond 'tired' IMF agenda?

By Atul Chandra, Vijay Prashad*  On September 22, 2024, the Sri Lankan election authority announced that Anura Kumara Dissanayake of the Janatha Vimukthi Peramuna (JVP)-led National People’s Power (NPP) alliance won the presidential election. Dissanayake, who has been the leader of the left-wing JVP since 2014, defeated 37 other candidates, including the incumbent president Ranil Wickremesinghe of the United National Party (UNP) and his closest challenger Sajith Premadasa of the Samagi Jana Balawegaya.