West Bengal death penalty bill 'an attempt to deflect attention from widespread protests'

By Kirity Roy*

The West Bengal government has put forth a new anti-rape bill that aims to impose capital punishment on individuals convicted of rape in cases where the victim dies or is left in a vegetative state. The West Bengal Legislative Assembly passed this controversial bill, titled 'Aparajita Woman and Child (West Bengal Criminal Laws Amendment) Bill, 2024,' with support from the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), the primary opposition party in the region.

This legislation has emerged in the wake of the tragic rape and murder of a trainee doctor at Kolkata’s RG Kar Medical College and Hospital. This horrifying incident, which took place on August 9, 2024, has shaken the nation's conscience. The brutal attack on a 31-year-old doctor at her workplace has highlighted significant failures within the State Health Department, the police investigation, and the broader administrative framework in West Bengal.

In response to this egregious act and the persistent demands for justice from citizens across the state, the West Bengal government introduced this bill, which many view as an attempt to deflect attention from the widespread protests against the systemic failures that allowed such violence to occur.

However, the introduction of the death penalty does not provide a comprehensive solution to the issue of crime, as it fails to tackle the underlying causes and intricacies of criminal behavior. There is no solid empirical evidence to suggest that capital punishment effectively deters crime. A civilized society cannot accept the notion of retribution through execution, as it merely perpetuates a cycle of violence.

Both Article 21 of the Indian Constitution and Article 3 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights underscore the right to life, liberty, and personal security, all of which are violated by the death penalty. To date, 112 countries have abolished capital punishment in all circumstances, while an additional 9 have done so for common law offenses, and 23 other nations are in the process of eliminating it. Nonetheless, 55 countries, including India, maintain the death penalty.

In the aftermath of the Nirbhaya rape and murder case, the Justice Verma Committee recommended against the death penalty

It is crucial to recognize that the fight for women’s rights is intrinsically linked to the struggle against systemic patriarchy in India. It is disheartening to see laws, courts, parliaments, and governmental bodies perpetuate a flawed system that fails to protect the vulnerable.

In the aftermath of the Nirbhaya rape and murder case, the Justice Verma Committee recommended against the death penalty, stating, "In the larger interests of society, and considering current sentiments favoring the abolition of the death penalty, we are not inclined to recommend such a punishment." Yet, ruling political parties continue to advocate for capital punishment as a means of delivering justice for personal and political agendas.

Mahatma Gandhi’s poignant assertion that “an eye for an eye makes the whole world blind” serves as a crucial reminder that violence cannot resolve violence. The cycle of revenge and state-sanctioned killings only exacerbates existing societal issues. True leadership should prioritize reconciliation over retribution.

---

*Secretary of Banglar Manabadhikar Suraksha Mancha (MASUM); National Convenor for the Programme Against Custodial Torture & Impunity (PACTI)

Comments

King Corona and his descendents: How long will the Dynasty last?

By Dr Amitav Banerjee, MD* “Corona ” is in the media once again, precipitating a déjà-vu feeling and some amount of panic among the people. Among viruses and microorganisms King Corona and its descendents enjoy Royalty Status. "What's in a name? That which we call a rose by any other name would smell as sweet." This classic quote from Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet is well known. But does it hold well in current times? The events during the past five years challenge the Bard's view.

The WHO Pandemic Agreement: Why India should reconsider its stance

By Dr Amitav Banerjee, MD* For more than the past three years, the WHO has been trying its best to push the Pandemic Treaty and amendments to the International Health Regulations in unholy haste, instead of conducting a proper appraisal of the impact of the measures taken during the Covid-19 pandemic—a routine exercise after any pandemic to guide future strategies. This raises questions about whether the WHO, under China’s influence, is trying to conceal its acts of omission and commission during the pandemic, including obstructing investigations into the origins of SARS-CoV-2. The WHO recently faced a setback when the USA decided to cut all ties with the organization.

Old bias, new excuses: How western media misrepresents India’s anti-terror strikes

By Gajanan Khergamker The recent Indian military strikes on Pakistan, dubbed Operation Sindoor, have sparked a storm of international media coverage. Several prominent outlets have portrayed India as the aggressor in the escalating conflict, raising concerns over biased reporting. This commentary critiques coverage by foreign media outlets such as The New York Times , Reuters, BBC, and CNN, which have often been accused of framing India’s actions as escalatory while downplaying or omitting critical context regarding Pakistan’s role in fostering terrorism. By examining historical patterns and current geopolitical dynamics, this analysis highlights the recurring selective framing, omission of evidence, and a tendency to favor narratives aligned with Western geopolitical interests over factual nuance.

India’s 2021 excess deaths: was it the virus — or the containment frenzy?

By Bhaskaran Raman* Tyagu (name changed), a vegetable vendor recalls of his brother’s death in 2021. The victim had a normal fever, but was forcibly taken away to the hospital saying that it was Covid. He had been coerced into taking the Covid-19 “vaccines” by that time. After 10 days in hospital, he died. There was no proper information during his hospital stay, and no one was allowed to visit, saying that visitors could also get Covid.

Killed in Chhattisgarh encounter, this Maoist leader suffered from overreliance on military actions

By Harsh Thakor* Namballa Keshava Rao, also known as Basav Raj, General Secretary of the banned CPI (Maoist), was killed in an encounter in which 27 Maoist cadre died during a security operation in the Abujhmad forest, Narayanpur district, Chhattisgarh, on the morning of May 21. This marks the first time in the history of the CPI (Maoist) that its General Secretary has been killed in an encounter. Rao is the second General Secretary after Charu Mazumdar to be killed by security forces.

Environmental report raises alarm: Sabarmati one of four rivers with nonylphenol contamination

By Rajiv Shah A new report by Toxics Link , an Indian environmental research and advocacy organisation based in New Delhi, in collaboration with the Environmental Defense Fund , a global non-profit headquartered in New York, has raised the alarm that Sabarmati is one of five rivers across India found to contain unacceptable levels of nonylphenol (NP), a chemical linked to "exposure to carcinogenic outcomes, including prostate cancer in men and breast cancer in women."

Crying air, water, and earth: A call to conserve our dying natural resources

By Dr. Gurinder Kaur* Air, water, and earth—these natural resources are essential for the survival of all living beings, including humans, animals, and plants. Life in any form is impossible without them. These are precious gifts of nature to humankind. However, in the pursuit of economic growth, modern humans have severely polluted these valuable resources in an attempt to satisfy their greed.

Ninety years of the socialist movement in India: What's the path head

By Dr. Sunilam* We are all aware of what the leaders active in the socialist movement have accomplished over the past 90 years. We are also well-acquainted with the sacrifices made by leaders and workers during the freedom struggle and the socialist movement. For the past 45 years, since I became interested in joining the socialist movement as an activist, I have been keen on understanding and analyzing its history. Inspired by 101-year-old freedom fighter Dr. G.G. Parikh and in collaboration with comrades from the Socialist Samagam, I have actively participated in organizing events to mark the 82nd, 85th, and now the 90th anniversaries of the socialist movement.

Search This Blog