Skip to main content

Gujarat's development dilemma

Arvind Kejriwal
By Rajiv Shah
A few days back, I received an email from a non-resident Indian, working as an expert researcher in a US consultancy firm which provides different types of financial services. He said he was googling around on Gujarat development issues and chanced to see my story, based on analysis carried out by an IAS officer who retired as additional chief secretary, Gujarat government, CJ Jose. He was “helping out” Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) in any possible way he could, and had followed Arvind Kejriwal’s visit to Gujarat closely. And, he had begun doing “some research” on the Gujarat development model, about which so much was being talked about. I am not revealing his name, as he asked me not to quote him.
Referring to my story, his email said, “I know Kejriwal has questioned Modi’s claims of more than 10 per cent agriculture growth, and has said Gujarat agriculture growth has been 1.18 per cent compound annual growth rate (CAGR), whereas you claim the growth to be 0.82 per cent. Could you please let me know where I could get the Gujarat agriculture data from so that I could do my own research? I went tohttp://agri.gujarat.gov.in/ (Gujarat agriculture department website) but couldn’t find any data there.”
I forwarded him another online story on Gujarat agriculture, based on the data provided to me by the state agriculture department, but not made public. It did not give any consolidated figure but suggested that between 2003-04 and 2012-13 Gujarat’s foodgrains production grew by 3.27 per cent per annum, cotton by 2.45 per cent, and oilseeds went down by (-) 2.71 per cent. The expert researched data online, and found that data till 2011-12 were available. But he again complained, he couldn’t get data for 2012-13. He wondered: “How did you get data from agriculture department? Did you file RTI?” I didn’t know what to say. Actually, I had obtained it from an official, who wanted the “latest real picture” to be made known.
The interaction with this researcher didn’t end here. I forwarded him a few more data on gross state domestic product (GSDP) of Gujarat, one of which said that, at current prices, Gujarat’s growth rate in 2012-13 was 13.98 per cent, based on which a Gujarat-based expert had guessed that the state’s real growth rate (at constant prices, after deducting inflation) wouldn’t be more than 7 per cent. The figure is based on advanced estimate in a budget document released in February 2013. I wondered, as the Gujarat government had still not released GSDP growth rate at constant prices, whether he could work it out.
His reply stunned me. He said: “The data you are using 13.98 per cent seems to be outdated.” These are based on Gujarat government’s fiscal responsibility report, which is “dated February 2013.” He added, “The GSDP of Gujarat was Rs 6,70,016 crore (at current prices) in 2012-13 as against 6,20,044 crore in 2011-12. That is a growth of 8.1 per cent (at current prices). The Rs 6,70,016 crore figure is from the Gujarat finance minister’s speech in February 2014. Also, I have Rs 6,20,044 crore figure for 2011-12 from the Wikipedia.” So, what would be the real growth rate of Gujarat, if it’s 8.1 per cent at current prices? Presuming the GDP deflator for Gujarat at 165.0, the real growth, he said, should be about 1.8 per cent!
Of course, he added a caveat: “Unfortunately, deflator is based on own judgment. Usually, it should be close to the consumer price index, but there has been divergence in the past. I read somewhere Gujarat inflation was below national average in 2012-13. Anyways, GDP deflator is known to be subject to manipulation by various governments. Given this is election year, I wouldn’t be surprised to see governments playing around with GDP deflator. Using a reasonable deflator of 165.0 (as against India’s 171.3), it seems real GDP growth (at constant prices) of Gujarat was not even be 2 per cent. Even if Gujarat plays around with deflator, real GDP growth doesn't look too good.”
I was left wondering: Why have experts in India, keenly debating Gujarat model, failed to see this simple fact? I decided to look at Gujarat finance minister Nitin Patel’s budget speech of February 2014, which had “proudly” proclaimed, “The GSDP (at current prices), which was Rs 1,11,139 crore in the year 2000-01, has increased to Rs 6,70,016 crore in the financial year 2012-13.” Indeed, the researcher was right. The Gujarat government had revised downwards its own estimate of GSDP for 2012-13 (at current prices) from Rs 6,97,298 crore to Rs 6,70,016 crore! I didn’t rely on Wikipedia figure for 2011-12, which mentions no source. I, instead, decided to refer to the current price GSDP data released by the Planning Commission.
What I got was this: Gujarat’s current price GSDP for 2011-12, according to the Planning Commission, was Rs 6,11,767 crore (as against Wikipedia’s Rs 6,20,044 crore). Gujarat was one of the three states which had not handed over their current price GSDP for 2012-13 to the Planning Commission – others being Kerala and Rajasthan. If one takes into consideration the state finance minister’s data of February 2014 – of Rs 6,70,016 crore GSDP in 2012-13 – the growth rate (at current price) would come to 9.52 per cent, as against the all-India average of 13.25 per cent. And this is the lowest compared to all major states!
This is the picture you get for other states (as reported by the Planning Commission) – Andhra Pradesh 13.83 per cent, Assam 13.45 per cent, Bihar 24.96 per cent, Chhattisgarh 14.82 per cent, Haryana 14.90 per cent, Himachal Pradesh 12.95 per cent, Jammu & Kashmir 12.72 per cent, Jharkhand 14.34 per cent, Karnataka 13.47 per cent, Madhya Pradesh 16.85 per cent, Maharashtra 14.43 per cent, Odisha 19.84 per cent, Punjab 13.88 per cent, Tamil Nadu 11.90 per cent, Uttar Pradesh 13.36 per cent, Uttarakhand 15.06 per cent, and West Bengal 16.89 per cent.
While it is not possible to know the real growth rate (at constant prices) in the absence of a reliable deflator, with 9.52 per cent of growth rate at current prices (lowest compared to all major states), there is reason to ask a pointed question: What has happened to the Gujarat model or its much-talked-about resilience to economic shocks and slowdown? What has happened to the strong “stabilizing influences” of Gujarat economy? And, if 2012-13 advanced estimates at current prices could be released in February 2013, why similar advanced estimates couldn’t be released in February 2014 while releasing the interim budget documents? It is because in 2013-14, again, Gujarat economy has performed badly?
---
https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/blogs/true-lies/gujarat-s-development-dilemma/

Comments

TRENDING

When phone tapping rumours were afloat in Gujarat among BJP leaders, IAS babus

Gordhan Zadaphia By Rajiv Shah While alerts were coming in over the last few days about a series of articles on how phones of “journalists, ministers, activists” may have been used to spy on them with the help of an Israeli project, Pegasus, finally, when I got up on Monday morning, I saw a Times of India story quoting (imagine!, we never used to do this, did just a followup in case we missed a story) the Wire, a top news portal on this providing some details, along with government reaction.

Gandhi Ashram 'redevelopment': Whither well-known Gandhi experts, Gandhians?

Sudarshan Iyengar, Ramchandra Guha By Rajiv Shah Rehabilitating about 200 families, mostly Dalits, living in the Gandhi Ashram premises by offering them Rs 60 lakh in order to implement a Rs 1,200 crore project called Gandhi Ashram Memorial and Precinct Development Project reportedly to bring the Ashram into its "original shape" as Gandhi established appears to me strange, to say the least.

Gandhi Ashram eviction: Finally historian Guha speaks out; but ageing trustees are silent

By Rajiv Shah Finally, at least one expert, top historian Ramachandra Guha, has spoken out on eviction of 200 families living in the Gandhi Ashram premises. Last week, I received an email alert from a veteran academic, Ashoke Chatterjee, former director, National Institute of Design (NID), Ahmedabad, which happens to be one of the most prestigious academic institutes of India based, informing me about it. NID is one of the several top institutes founded when Jawaharlal Nehru was India’s Prime Minister.

Will Vaishnaw, close to Modi since Vajpayee days, ever be turnaround man for Railways?

By Rajiv Shah Ever since Ashwini Vaishnaw was appointed as railway minister, I was curious to know who he was and how did he come closer to Prime Minister Narendra Modi and, most important, when. Hence, I decided to talk with some Sachivalaya officials in Gujarat in order to find out if there was, if any, Gujarat (or Modi) connection.

Non-entity 6 yrs ago, Indian state turned Fr Stan into world class human rights defender

Jharkhand's Adivasi women  By Rajiv Shah A lot is being written on Father Stan Swamy, a Jesuit priest who is known more for his work for tribal rights in Jharkhand. His death at the age of 84, even when he was an under trial prisoner for his alleged involvement in the Bhima Koregaon violence three years go, has, not without reason, evoked sharp reaction, not just in India but across the world.

Home Ministry data vs Health Ministry data! Gujarat's poor sex ratio at birth data

Home minister Amit Shah, health minister Harsh Vardhan By Rajiv Shah Don’t India’s top ministries – of Health and Family Welfare (MoHFW) and of Home Affairs (MoHA) – tally data before releasing them? It would seem so… A few days back, I did a story in Counterview , based on an MoHA report, stating that Gujarat has the lowest sex rate at birth (SRB) at 901 girls as against 1000 births, followed by Assam (903), Madhya Pradesh (905) and Jammu & Kashmir (909), raising valid apprehensions that widescale female foeticide may be prevalent in India’s “model” State.

July 1: Observing communal harmony day in Ahmedabad, a highly segregated city

Activists at Vasant-Rajab memorial on July 1 By Rajiv Shah Celebrated as Communal Harmony Day in Ahmedabad, July 1, 2021 is remembered for the sacrifice of two friends, Vasant Rao Hegishte and Rajab Ali Lakhani, laid down their lives for the cause of communal harmony on the July 1, 1946 in the city. A memorial stands in their memory in Khandni Sheri, Jamalpur, Ahmedabad.

Periyar opposed imposition of alien culture on Dravidian people, but wasn't anti-Hindi

By  Vidya Bhushan Rawat* Thiru K Veeramani is the ideological disciple of EVR Periyar and one of the senior most leaders of the Dravidian movement at the moment. He started working under his mentor EVR Periyar at the age of 10 years when he delivered his first speech in Salem. Veeramani is President of Dravidar Kazhagam and editor of Modern Rationalist, a monthly journal devoted to Periyar’s ideas. That apart, he is editor of many other magazines and journals in Tamil. This interview was conducted by Vidya Bhushan Rawat at the Periyar Thidal on November 1st, 2019. These are some of the excerpts and the entire interview can be viewed at the youtube link being provided at the end of the article. Dravidian movement internationally Thiru Veeramani said that “It is high time that Periyar must be globalised now. He said that it was easier in relation to Dr Ambedkar since he has written in English and almost all the western audience read him through his work. But the southern part of India

Positive side of Vaishnaw? Ex-official insists: Give him loss making BSNL, Air India

By Rajiv Shah A senior chartered accountant, whom I have known intimately (I am not naming him, as I don’t have his permission), has forwarded me an Indian Express (IE) story (July 18), “Ashwini Vaishnaw: The man in the chair”, which, he says, “contradicts” the blog (July 17), "Will Vaishnaw, close to Modi since Vajpayee days, ever be turnaround man for Railways?" I had written a day earlier and forwarded it to many of my friends.

Gujarat cadre woman IAS official who objected to Modi remark on sleeveless blouse

By Rajiv Shah Two days back, a veteran journalist based in Patna, previously with the Times of India, Ahmedabad, phoned me up to inform me that he had a sad news: Swarnakanta Varma, a retired Gujarat cadre IAS bureaucrat, who was acting chief secretary on the dastardly Godhra train burning day, February 27, 2002, which triggered one of the worst ever communal riots in Gujarat, has passed away due to Covid. “I have been informed about this from a friend in Jaipur, where she breathed her last”, Law Kumar Mishra said.