How government guide misguided people about ASI-controlled historical site Modhera

I visited Modhera, a historical site of abandoned sun temple, built in the 11th century, the other day with family friends who had come from New Jersey. Situated about 100 from Ahmedabad, I got interested in how the expert guide had sought to identify its destruction.

The guide insisted (he claimed to have been certified by the government), the temple was destroyed first by Mahmud of Ghazni and then by Alauddin Khilji, though there seemed to be little expert confirmation -- quite unlike the Somnath temple, about which a Gujarat government site points how it was destroyed 17 times over, including by Mahmud of Ghazni in the 1299 century and then by Aurangzeb in 1706.
Though it is essentially an abandoned sun temple, protected by the Archeological Survey of India, the guide talked of how it represented different gods and goddesses, including Radha and Krishna, and Ram and Sita. No expert references to the site talks of this.

Later, we went to the museum, an elderly person was seemed quite worked up after listening to the guide. He approached me, stating, "See, Alauddin Khilji destroyed this site. But for the Mughals, who destroyed it, this would have been a live temple."
I asked him whether Alauddin Khilji was a Mughal, and he nodded. Then I told him the year when Alauddin Khilji, a Delhi Sultanate ruler of the 14th century, ruled. I asked tell me find when the Mughals came to India. And he had no India!

Comments

The dye is caste in Gujarat

I think it was 1994 when I first met Japanese scholar Takashi Shinoda, an Indologist, during my routine visit to the Sardar Patel Institute of Economic and Social Research, Ahmedabad, at that time still known for some quality research. Once headed such academics of highest order such as DT Lakdawala and YK Alagh, the institute has since collapsed – at least this is what I learn from Gujarat’s academic circles, with whom I had developed good rapport before I was shifted to Gandhinagar to report on government affairs for the Times of India in 1997. Unassuming, Shinoda took me to the institute canteen for tea, and told me of his latest area of interest – social mobility and occupational diversification of different castes over several decades. What he told me was indeed of great interest to me – that Gujarat’s “enterprising” Patels, who I thought till then were mainly a farming community, had still not overtaken the Banias in business. However, he underlined, “The way things are happening...

Jay Somnath

Kanhaiyalal Maneklal Munshi This is what happened several decades ago, when I was a small school-going child. Every summer, accompanied with my mother, I would come down from Delhi to spend the two-month-long holiday at my maternal uncle’s place in the posh Panchvati area of Ahmedabad. Each weekend, my uncle would take us for a ride in his grand old black car. I think it was Chevrolet. I would wait eagerly for the weekend, as I had virtually nothing to do for the rest of the days. In the evenings, I mostly play in the open ground with the neighbouring children, but for rest of the time, as if, I was under strict, almost loving, control of my grandma, whom all of the children of the family called Baa. Especially after the dinner, which would be pretty early, she would make it a point to entertain us – mainly me and my cousin – by playing bezique. During one such summer, Baa decided to give us a strong injection of nationalism. She took in her hand Kanhaiyalal Maneklal Munshi’s well-kno...

China's hukou and India's caste: A comparison that ignores the Jianmin

The other day, I saw an interesting article, "Does China have a caste system or is it a figment of imagination of Indians?" It wonders whether "China, the world's manufacturing powerhouse and a socialist state governed by a Communist party", has a birth-based caste system that shapes access to education, healthcare, and opportunity.

RajivBuzz

Search This Blog