Modi tax?

Jayanthi Natarajan

BJP’s prime ministerial aspirant Narendra Modi was in Goa in January second week. He took a jibe at former Union environment and forests minister Jayanthi Natarajan – saying there was a “Jayanthi tax” when she was in charge of the ministry. Modi alleged many files in the ministry were pending only because of a new tax in Delhi called “Jayanthi tax”, and unless it was “paid” no file would move. "We've heard of income tax, sales tax, commercial tax in the past, but this is the first time we are hearing of a Jayanthi tax!" he declared. When he made the remark, I humbly thought, what’s new about it. Politicians of all hues are alike. They all charge a “tax” for all that they do. My experience in Gandhinagar as correspondent wasn’t any different.
Indeed, I wasn’t wrong. My friend Mahesh Pandya, who, as environmental engineer (he calls himself environmental expert; “I am not an environmentalist”, he says), moves around Gujarat campaigning on environmental issues with all his energy, tells me if that there was Jayanthi tax in Delhi (and which may be continuing under some new name now), there is reason to be believe that there is “Modi tax” in Gujarat. Citing a Right to Information (RTI) application filed by one Kirit Rathod, Pandya adds, as of December 2013, as many as 1,739 projects are awaiting environmental clearance with the Gujarat government. Reason? Because the state government has failed to form a new State-level Environmental Appraisal Committee (SEAC), which expired in July 2013.
Pandya has had some success in establishing himself as an environmental crusader, yet I decided to take all that he was saying with a pinch of salt. I called for the RTI reply, which I got. Then I contacted a senior Sachivalaya official to know what the reality was. The official told me that there are two types of environmental clearances, Category A and Category B. If Category A environmental clearances “must go to Delhi for a nod”, Category B are “not serious enough, hence don’t need a Delhi nod”. They can be cleared in the state itself, without any issues. They just need a nod of the SEAC, and that’s it. So, my question was, why were so many projects pending, as the RTI reply had said.
“There is no SEAC in Gujarat ever since it expired in July 2013. There was a certain delay in sending an application for Government of India nod to constitute SEAC, as required. We moved it in November 2013, though it should have been sent to Delhi sometime in January 2013. If that was done, the necessary clearance could have been obtained and we would have had a new SEAC by August 2013. We hope to get an okay from Delhi soon. We think that the new SEAC would be formed in mid-February. Once the application is cleared, the pending projects under the Category B, requiring state clearance, too, would be cleared without much problem”, the official, known for his suave nature, told me. His answer amused me.
In Sachivalaya, it is widely rumoured, this official was one of the “authors” of Modi’s book “Convinient Action: Gujarat's Response to Challenges of Climate Change”. Modi often claimed his book was an answer to issues raised in “An Inconvenient Truth”, a 2006 Academy Award winning documentary film on former US vice-president Al Gore's campaign to educate citizens about global warming. Released in December 2010, Modi made a big show out of the book – he roped in former President APJ Abdul Kalam and The Energy and Resource Institute (TERI) director-general RK Pachauri to release it and made an official of the Macmillan Publishers India Ltd to declare that he was the “second political leader to write a book on climate change” following Al Gore!
It is quite another thing that Modi’s “Climate Change” served as a coffee table book for a little while in the elegant chambers of Sachivalaya babus, and then disappeared to their bookshelves. Few read it, and those who tried doing it, frankly said, it contained “nothing but a compilation of well-edited Gujarat government press notes and some very good photographs.” In 2009, Modi declared that Gujarat had become the first state to have a climate change department. Five years have passed, yet we don’t have a full-time climate change secretary. Worse, the state government’s Gujarat State Wide Area Network (GSWAN), on its sites page, at the very fag end, does mention climate change department, but you click on it and you reach Gujarat Energy Development Agency (GEDA). GEDA is in existence for the more than three decades promoting alternative sources of energy in Gujarat, starting with the Surya Cooker in 1979!
Meanwhile, how serious has the Gujarat government been about climate change or environment can be gauged from following facts: The Gujarat government got cleared from the SEAC few of the high-profile projects, crucial for Modi’s image makeup, quite some time after they were implemented! One of them was Mahatma Mandir, the huge complex where Vibrant Gujarat global business summits and other top events are held in Gandhinagar. The SEAC was made to clear it “post-facto”. The same happened with as many as eight malls, built in Ahmedabad and propagated as the new face of Ahmedabad. Then, there are other government-sponsored high-profile projects like Sabarmati River Front or Sardar Statue in the Narmada river, about which officials declare, without mincing words, that “there no need to take their environmental clearance.”
---
This blog was first published in The Times of India

Comments

Beyond the 'plum' posting: Why the caste lens still defines bureaucratic success

Following my recent blog on former IAS bureaucrat Atanu Chakraborty’s sudden exit as non-executive chairman of HDFC Bank, a few colleagues from the Gujarat cadre — mostly those I interacted with during my Gandhinagar stint (1997–2012) as the Times of India representative — reacted rather sharply. Most of them sent their responses directly on WhatsApp, touching upon on the merits and demerits of Chakraborty’s controversial move. One former IAS officer, a Dalit, however, went further, raising a broader question: why do some officials like Chakraborty secure plum post-retirement assignments, while others are overlooked?

A Hindu alternative to Valentine's Day? 'Shiv-Parvati was first love marriage in Universe'

The other day, I was searching on Google a quote on Maha Shivratri which I wanted to send to someone, a confirmed Shiv Bhakt, quite close to me -- with an underlying message to act positively instead of being negative. On top of the search, I chanced upon an article in, imagine!, a Nashik Corporation site which offered me something very unusual. I don't know who owns this site, for there is nothing on it in the About Us link. It merely says, the Nashik Corporation site "is an educational and news website of the municipal corporation. Today, education and payment of tax are completely online." It goes on to add, "So we provide some of the latest information about Property Tax, Water Tax, Marriage Certificate, Caste Certificate, etc. So all taxpayer can get all information of their municipal in a single place.some facts about legal and financial issues that different city corporations face, but I was least interested in them." Surely, this didn't interest...

Population as destiny: The dangerous logic of India's new delimitation move

Dr. Narasimha Reddy Donthi, a noted public policy expert and public interest campaigner, in a detailed critical analysis of two Bills introduced in Parliament in April 2026—the Constitution (131st Amendment) Bill, 2026 and the Delimitation Bill, 2026 , has warned that the twin bills "raise significant constitutional, political and methodological concerns — most critically, a structural inconsistency in the census basis used for Parliament versus State Assemblies, and an over-reliance on population as the sole parameter for delimitation."

Blaming RTE, not underfunding: Education groups hit back at NITI Aayog working paper

A preliminary working paper by Arvind Virmani, economist and member of the Government of India think tank NITI Aayog, has concluded that the Right to Education (RTE) Act — enacted to guarantee free and compulsory schooling for children between six and fourteen — has actually worsened learning outcomes rather than improved them. The paper, published in March 2026 and reported by The Print on 16 April, has drawn sharp pushback from education rights advocates, who argue it builds a politically motivated narrative against constitutionally guaranteed entitlements.

Exile, empire and memory: Khergamker's '10/3' invites researchers into a living archive

Author and legal commentator Gajanan Khergamker has made his ebook '10/3: Exile, Empire And War In The Andamans' publicly accessible online, a month after its limited offline digital launch on 10 March 2026. What began as a publication has, in Khergamker's own framing, transformed into a live, evolving research framework — Project 10/3 — inviting participation from researchers, institutions and citizens.

No gas in cities, no work in villages: Double disaster for India’s migrants

A perfect storm of geopolitical crisis and policy paralysis is pushing India’s poorest into a devastating double-bind. The ongoing war in Iran has sent shockwaves through global oil markets, and as LPG prices skyrocket and factory slowdowns ripple across urban centers, a massive exodus of migrant workers is underway. But for millions fleeing the city’s hardships, the safety net of rural employment has all but vanished, leaving them stranded without work or income.

Civil society flags widespread violations of land acquisition Act before Parliamentary panel

Civil society organisations and stakeholders from across India have presented stark evidence before the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Rural Development and Panchayati Raj , alleging systemic violations of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement (RFCTLARR) Act, 2013 , particularly in Scheduled Areas and tribal regions.

The financial engine behind America’s 'toxic' petrochemical expansion, claims report

A new report, Toxic Finance , has sought to expose the critical role of the global financial sector in driving a massive and controversial expansion of the petrochemical industry across the United States. The analysis, compiled by a coalition of environmental and human rights organizations including the Center for International Environmental Law (CIEL) and Break Free From Plastic , claims that banks and investors have provided the vast sums of capital necessary to build over 100 new facilities or expansions, despite significant risks to human health, the climate, and the financial system itself.

Ambedkar’s radical legacy fueled resurgence in Gujarat Dalit agitations: Study

Over the past decade and a half, Gujarat has witnessed a remarkable resurgence of Dalit agitations that mark a decisive shift from accommodation to confrontation, according to a major new study published in the journal National Identities . The research, conducted by Mahendra Parmar of the Central University of Gujarat , draws on 18 in-depth interviews with victims and activists to document how B.R. Ambedkar ’s radical thought has become the central political resource shaping Dalit identity and mobilisation in the state.

Search This Blog