Skip to main content

Manual scavenging: Neglect of smaller towns evident, says NGO survey

By Rajiv Shah 
Despite the law against manual scavenging, which was made more stringent by Indian Parliament recently, new facts have come to light which go to suggest that Gujarat’s smaller towns are some the worst victims of the despicable age-old practice of manually removing excreta, imposed upon the valimiki community for generations. A recent case of Dholka town, situated around 50 kilometres from Ahmedabad, suggests that despite repeated reminders by NGOs fighting against manual scavenging, the state officialdom has failed come out its slumber, the practice continues till date.
The matter first came to light after a petition was filed by Manjula Pradeep, director, Navsarjan Trust, a Gujarat-based human rights, before the National Human Rights Commission (HHRC) in January 2013. She drew attention of the NHRC about “lack of basic facilities in Dholka town”, alleging, “The situation of public dry latrines and vaada toilets is very pathetic. There is no water facility in the toilets. The doors of toilets are broken. The open drainages are full of human waste and uncollected garbage. Because of extreme filth, people are defecating in the open. Basic facilities like clean drinking water, drainage, street light etc. are lacking in the city. Sanitation workers from the municipality are cleaning this vaada latrine and the prohibited work of manual scavenging is going on”.
The petitioner describes the miserable conditions prevailing in most various parts of Dholka, attaching alongside a survey of the town carried out by the Navsarjan Trust. She states that things have not improved despite several reminders, starting with a memorandum was submitted to the sub-divisional magistrate of Dholka November 16, 2009.
The Urban Development and Urban Housing Department, Government of Gujarat, submitted a report dated November 1, 2012, which claimed that the Dholka municipality had taken several steps to improve facilities in slum areas. The details of the works carried out include underground drainage at three different places, two of which had been completed; sanctioning of a total of 2,485 individual toilets between 2006-2007 and 2011-12; and setting up of eight pay-and-use toilets, adjoining the areas of public toilets. The municipality also decided to build more pay-and-use toilets.
On the basis of all this, the state government told the NHRC that the municipality “has tried to solve the problems of people and no violation of fundamental rights of the scheduled castes or any discrimination by the municipality has taken place in Dholka.” Yet, facts collected by the Navsarjan Trust volunteers suggest that while some of the toilets have been made and others are in the process of being constructed, manual scavenging per se remains intact, like before.
While construction of toilets has taken place in upper caste areas, the spots where the lower castes, particularly the Dalits, live, remain neglected like before. In fact, at several places, open defecation is rampant even today. The volunteers have found that at some places the municipality has not demolished the dry toilets, especially in the Dalit areas, nor have any individual toilets or no-pay-and-use toilets been constructed. Pradeep has told NHRC, “The state government report does not refer to certain areas such as Chitravada, Khijda Sheri, Zandiya Kuva, Sonar Kui/Bar Kotha and Sonar Kui/Vaghari Vas” at all. Based on her response, the NHRC on May 30, 2013 issued a fresh notice to the Gujarat government to submit a reply within four weeks. However, till date, it has not submitted any report.
Meanwhile, referring to Khastriya-Thakor Vas, Dholka municipality claims it has “eradicated open defecation and the uses of manual scavenging since 1981.” The public toilet in these areas, it says, has been “cleaned by using Maljet machine and the drainage water is being pumped into underground drainage line”. It adds, “Water supply has been arranged through a separate lock, tap and door to each units of the public toilet.” At the same time, it admits, local public theft is rampant, with taps and the lock being stolen. Hence, municipality decided to stop the public toilet and also put notice for the general public about it.
The Navsarjan Trust observes, “As people from the nearby areas do not have their own individual toilet, open defecation continues. In another area, Gundra, Dholka municipality claims to have eradicated the usage of manual scavenging by constructing pay-and-Use toilets, and even constructed individual toilets in the area, but public toilets are closed. It also constructed four dry latrine toilets (two for men and two for women) for this scheduled caste area.”
It adds, “Its cleaning is carried out by a particular municipality’s Safai Kamdar as open defecation continues in this area. In Chui Fali, too, open defecation is continuing. Beneficiaries entitled to individual toilets in the SC area have not gained. Manual scavenging also continues Chitravada, Khijda Sheri , Zandiya Kuva, Sonar Kui and Vaghari Vas, yet there is no reply on action taken on the part of the Dholka municipality.”
All this continues despite the fact that NHRC chairman KG Balakrishnan was requested about two years ago urgent action against the violation of “the fundamental rights of the scheduled castes (SCs) in Dholka city, Ahmedabad district, in the Form of discrimination by the local Dholka municipality against the SCs.” In a letter to Balakrishnan, Pradeep wondered why “people do not have their primary facilities like concrete roads, underground drainage system and safe drinking water” Dholka, even as there “are heaps of uncollected garbage in many streets and public places in the city.”
She said, “The state government’s Nirmal Gujarat Mission, ie the total sanitation drive, is supposed to provide cleanliness to every city in Gujarat, but Dholka city’s people have not seen any change whatsoever.” Though a memorandum to the sub-divisional magistrate of Dholka depicting facts by a citizen’s rights committee, “no proper action was taken by him”.

The memorandum reads, "The City Development Department of the Gujarat State Government created the “Nirmal Gujarat” scheme as a strategy for the development of cities. But SC areas and undeveloped rural areas of Gujarat do not get the advantages of these facilities. Dholka municipality has established eight pay and use toilets for the public. Out of which the toilets located in Popatpara, Brahmin Pith, and the Taluka Panchayat area are dysfunctional and the other toilets which are functional do not remain open for public use 24 hours a day. In this situation, the municipality uses sanitation workers for cleaning these dry toilets and vaada toilets, despite the fact that this work is prohibited under Act.”
The memorandum provides details of each area:
(a) Chitarvada: In this area there is a population of 500 people from Muslim, Thakor and Patel communities. The local school is situated in this area and it is in front of the municipality. A public toilet, in which there is no water facility, is also built in front of school. This toilet is filled up with human waste, which spills out into the public road. As a result, children of the school and the local people’s health are at risk. Also, school children and buffaloes have fallen into an open manhole in this area. Information about this situation has been provided often by the school organizers to the municipality, but they are not taking any action. It is necessary that the dry latrines are to be converted into flush latrines and filth has to be removed from this area.
(b) Khijda Sheri: In this area there are 750 people from various castes, including Vankar, Valmiki, Brahmin, Devi Poojak, Raval and Patel communities. A Vaada latrine is directly adjacent to the Valimiki area, and it is used by people from all of the above castes for defecation. Because of the filthiness of human excrement, people in this area often suffer from serious sickness. Water is not regularly available in this area and there is problem of Street lighting as well. Sanitation workers from the municipality are cleaning this vaada latrine and the prohibited work of manual scavenging is going on.
(c) Zandiya Kuva: The population of people from Vankar, Valmiki, Muslim and Devi Poojak communities in this area is 450. Adjacent to the Valmiki caste area, an old vaada latrine is constructed by the municipality. Here also, there is no water facility so the filth overflows in the open gutters. Dry latrines have been constructed in this area by the municipality, but their doors are broken and it creates filth and odour in the area putting local people’s health at risk. Drainage, street lighting and water are also other issues in this area.
(c) Kshatriya Thakor Vas: The population in this area is 600, made up of people from Thakor, Devi Poojak, Muslim and Bharwad communities. There are dry latrines under supervision of the Nagarpalika on the road sides, but their doors are in broken condition and as a result, women face many difficulties. Dry latrines and open drainages are full of human waste, so people defecate in the open and again women face more problems. This is the main road of the city so anyone using the road and the local people are affected from the filth. Health is the major issue of the people in this area.
(e) Govaliya Vas: The population in this area is mostly from Thakor and Muslim communities. There are dry latrines constructed by the Nagarpalika both for men and women. Approximately 300 people use these dry latrines every day. Human filth overflows from the toilets and gutters due to lack of water facility. Their doors are in broken condition, resulting in humiliating situations for many women. There is heaps of uncollected garbage around the toilets. Open gutters are situated in front of residential areas, resulting in regular sickness amongst the residents. Information about this situation has been provided on many occasions to the Nagarpalika, but they have not taken any action. Sanitation workers from the Nagarpalika are cleaning this vaada latrine and the prohibited work of manual scavenging is going on.
(f) Gundra: The population in this area is made up of people from Valmiki, Devi Poojak, and Patel communities. There are dry latrines constructed by the Nagarpalika in this area. Lack of proper drainage, street lighting and housing are the main issues being faced by people in this area. Dry latrines are consistently full of human waste, resulting in frequent sickness of people in this area.
(g) Chui Fali: The population in this area is 350, made up of people from Valmiki, Devi Poojak, and Muslim communities. There are dry latrines in this area, and half of them have fallen down and are being used and are filled up with human waste. As a result, people defecate in the open. There are heaps of uncollected garbage and human waste in the area around the toilets. The health of Valmiki people in this area is at serious risk. Basic facilities such as clean water, proper drainage, street lighting and housing are not provided in this area by the Nagarpalika.
(h)Sonar Kui/Bar Kotha: The population in this area is 700, made up of people from Valmiki, Devi Poojak, and Vankar communities. There are dry latrines and vada toilets in this area; they are full of human waste, resulting in an intolerable odour faced by people in this area. The vaada toilets and dry toilets of this area and other areas are being cleaned by Ishwarbhai Somabhai Purabiya.
(i)Sonar kui / Vaghri Vas: The population in this area is 300, made up of people from Devi Poojak and Thakor communities. Because of human waste from dry latrines and uncollected garbage, the health of local people is at risk. Primary and basic facilities like clean water, proper drainage, C.C, road are not provided in this area by the Nagarpalika.
The memorandum insists, “The resolutions relating to Scheduled castes special component plan and urban development and urban housing construction development, Gandhinagar have not been implemented in the above mentioned areas by Dholka municipality. As a result, the residential area of the city in which people from Scheduled Castes live have not received clean public toilets and toilets for women, clean concrete roads, clean proper drainage, or clean drinking water."
In light of the above, the memorandum says, the people of Dholka city are demanding the basic facilities that are their rights. The main demands are:
  • All facilities should be budgeted under a scheme titled Development of Dirty Areas, and under the Scheduled Castes Special Component Plan
  • Uncollected garbage, human waste, and other dangerous waste must be removed from the city, urgently
  • Manual scavengers are forced to clean and maintain public dry toilets and vaada toilets. This work is prohibited under law. Criminal proceedings should be taken against the chief officer and chairperson of the Dholka Nagarpalika, and they must be dismissed immediately
  • All pay and use toilets should remain open for 24 hours
  • Urinals and toilets with water facilities for women must be constructed in each ward
  • The area in which people from SCs live lacks basic facilities. Hence development work should begin immediately in accordance with the Government’s own scheme entitled under “SC component plan”
  • All public roads in the Dholka city should be made of RCC
  • In accordance with the Nirmal Gujarat scheme, facility for urinals and toilets with underground drainage system must be provided in every home
  • All open drainage in the city should be converted into underground drainage

Comments

TRENDING

Towards 2024: Time for ‘We the People of India’ to wake up before it is too late

By Fr Cedric Prakash SJ*  It is Constitution Day once again! We, the people of India, gratefully remember 26 November 1949 when the Constitution of India was passed and adopted by the Constituent Assembly. The Constituent Assembly comprised women and men of distinction, who were able to represent the heart and soul of the people of India without fear or favour. They gave of their best, so that we may a visionary Constitution, which would be the mainstay for and of democracy in India!

Regretful: Kapil Dev retired not leaving Indian cricket with integrity he upheld

By Harsh Thakor  Kapil Dev scaled heights as an entertainer and a player upholding the spirit of the game almost unparalleled in his era. In his time he was cricket’s ultimate mascot of sportsmanship On his day Kapil could dazzle in all departments to turn the tempo of game in the manner of a Tsunami breaking in. He radiated r energy, at a level rarely scaled in his era on a cricket field. Few ever blended aggression with artistry so comprehenisively. Although fast medium, he could be as daunting with the ball as the very best, with his crafty outswinger, offcutter, slower ball and ball that kicked from a good length. Inspite of bowling on docile tracks on the subcontinent, Kapil had 434 scalps, with virtually no assistance. I can never forget how he obtained pace and movement on flat pancakes, trapping the great Vivian Richards in Front or getting Geoff Boycott or Zaheer Abbas caught behind. No paceman carried the workload of his team’s bowling attack on his shoulders in his eras muc

How the slogan Jai Bhim gained momentum as movement of popularity and revolution

By Dr Kapilendra Das*  India is an incomprehensible plural country loaded with diversities of religions, castes, cultures, languages, dialects, tribes, societies, costumes, etc. The Indians have good manners/etiquette (decent social conduct, gesture, courtesy, politeness) that build healthy relationships and take them ahead to life. In many parts of India, in many situations, and on formal occasions, it is common for people of India to express and exchange respect, greetings, and salutation for which we people usually use words and phrases like- Namaskar, Namaste, Pranam, Ram Ram, Jai Ram ji, Jai Sriram, Good morning, shubha sakal, Radhe Radhe, Jai Bajarangabali, Jai Gopal, Jai Jai, Supravat, Good night, Shuvaratri, Jai Bhole, Salaam walekam, Walekam salaam, Radhaswami, Namo Buddhaya, Jai Bhim, Hello, and so on.

Critical factors that determine, contribute to the success and effectiveness of NGOs

By Rohit Rakshit  Over the last few years, I have been fortunate to work with numerous non-governmental organizations (NGOs) across various states in the country. This experience has allowed me to gain insights into their diverse areas of work while also enabling me to analyze the key attributes that contribute to the success of a good NGO. According to my observations, the following are the critical factors that determine the effectiveness of an NGO.

Polytechnic Uprising 50 years ago even today inspires radical Greek youth movement

By Harsh Thakor*  On November 17, progressive sections in Greece marked the 50th anniversary of the Athens Polytechnic Uprising of 1973. A massive rally from the Athens Polytechnic passed through various parts of the city, including the US Embassy. Thousands of activists from the Communist Party of Greece (KKE), Communist Youth of Greece (KNE), Students Struggle Front (MAS), Federation of Greek Women (OGE), Hellenic Committee for International Detente and Peace (EEDYE), and All Workers Militant Front (PAME), among other groups, participated in the march denouncing imperialism, fascism and military dictatorship.

Delhi labour chowk workers get work for 15 days a month, 10% get grain on ration cards

By Bharat Dogra*  It is around 10 in the morning and the number of workers at the Sigalpur labor chowk in Shalimar Bagh area of Delhi is increasing. As a worker Munna says: “The hope of getting any work is much lesser now due to pollution related ban on construction but still workers assemble here in the hope of getting at least some minor repair or other work.”

How adamant Bellsonika management is continuously robbing workers' livelihood

By Harsh Thakor*  On September 27th, earlier this year, the Bellsonika Workers’ Union was stripped of legal status or registration. The Haryana government's labour department cancelled the registration of the Bellsonica workers' union over granting the membership to one of the 'contractual workers'. It was major breach on Constitutional Rights of workers, to enable the contract labour system to flourish, and tighten the noose on any form of workers resistance.

Day to remember hardship, sincere efforts of Dr Ambedkar for framing Constitution

By Dr Kapilendra Das  The 26th of November, the day of an important landmark in India's journey as an Independent, Sovereign, socialist, secular, and Democratic, Republic is celebrated as National Constitution Day in India, also known as Samvidhan Divas. On this day the constituent Assembly adopted the constitution of India in 1949 to secure the Indian Citizen's justice, liberty, equality, and union which came into effect two months later, on January 26, 1950, and India became a Republic.

TERI researchers outline ways for robust, equitable and flexible outcome at COP28

By Sanya Hans  Researchers at The Energy and Resources Institute (TERI) launched two crucial policy briefs ahead of the much anticipated 28th Conference of the Parties (COP28) scheduled from November 30 to December 12, 2023 at Dubai, UAE.  Former climate negotiator, Ambassador Manjeev Singh Puri, a Distinguished Fellow at TERI emphasized, “Adaptation is an imperative and absolute must in present times for the Global South. COP28 needs to make the Global Goal on Adaptation (GGA) integral to climate commitments and action”.  “Climate change demands that energy use must be sustainable; the development imperative of the Global South demands it to be inclusive, just and fair," Mr Puri added.   Outcome on GGA will be a key determinant for the success of COP28   The policy brief titled ‘Road to Dubai and The Global Goal on Adaption’ reviewed the discussions around the GGA framework to provide perspectives on what could be a robust, equitable, and flexible outcome of the GGA process at CO

Raising temperature of frozen foods by 3 degrees from -18°C to -15°C can slash carbon emissions: Study

By Payel Sannigrahi  Frozen food temperatures could be changed by just three degrees to save the carbon dioxide emissions of 3.8 million cars per year, research suggests.