Skip to main content

India needs Gandhi so it doesn’t become a Hindu Pakistan: Ramachandra Guha

 
Renowned historian and biographer Ramachandra Guha delivered a wide-ranging special lecture titled "Gandhi: His Life, Ideas and Enduring Legacy" in Ahmedabad to mark the launch of his latest book, Arguments with Gandhi (Fourth Estate/HarperCollins). Introduced by writer, satirist, and India After Gandhi Gujarati co-translator and publisher Urvish Kothari, Guha offered a candid examination of Mahatma Gandhi’s evolving philosophy, his fiercest critics across the ideological spectrum, and why his ideas remain vital for contemporary India.
Beyond Hagiography and Trolling
Clarifying that his third major work on Gandhi was not written as a "Gandhi bhakt" or a blind advocate, Guha emphasized that Arguments with Gandhi is an effort to understand history by giving Gandhi’s critics full space. Divided into four parts—non-violence, justice, faith, and progress—the book examines the global debates surrounding Gandhi’s ideas and his afterlife in places like the United States and South Africa.
Guha traced the roots of his Gandhi scholarship back to 1996, when he was invited to teach at the University of California. At the time, he noticed a surge in "trolling" against Gandhi from both the extreme right and the extreme left—a phenomenon he noted has persisted for over three decades. Immersing himself in contrasting texts, from Louis Fischer’s A Week with Gandhi (1942) and The Life of Mahatma Gandhi (1950) to B.R. Ambedkar’s Annihilation of Caste, Guha decided to investigate these ideological battles using archival material and intelligence reports from the Nehru Memorial Museum, Gandhi Ashram, and the British Museum.
Origins of Non-Violence and Environmental Foresight
Addressing the origins of satyagraha, Guha noted that Gandhi’s commitment to non-violence was deeply rooted in his upbringing in Kathiawar, where he observed farmers negotiating with and resisting unjust princely rulers and heavy taxation. He was also profoundly inspired by the non-violent suffragette movement of women fighting for voting rights in England.
Guha also highlighted Gandhi as a pioneering environmentalist and a sharp critic of Western-style industrial urban civilization. Quoting Gandhi’s prescient warning from 1928, Guha recalled how Gandhi argued that if a tiny island nation like England required massive exploitation to industrialize, a vast country like India adopting the same model would destroy the environment manifold.
Gandhi vs. Lenin and the Left
Drawing a historical parallel between Gandhi and Vladimir Lenin—born just six months apart—Guha noted that 1917 marked both the Champaran Satyagraha and the Russian Revolution, forcing young Indians to choose between two radically different paths to liberation.
Marxist hostility toward Gandhi began around 1917, led by figures like M.N. Roy, who dismissed non-violence as irrelevant and accused Gandhi of keeping the masses in the dark through his reliance on religion and God. Guha pointed out that this animosity persisted for decades, citing police records documenting 179 incidents in West Bengal during Gandhi’s birth centenary year in which Naxalites desecrated his statues, as well as Ahmedabad Marxist C.G. Shah dismissing Gandhi as "bourgeois."
Evolution on Race, Gender, and Caste
Confronting modern criticisms directly, Guha acknowledged that Gandhi held racial prejudices against Black people in his early years in South Africa, calling them lazy. However, Guha stressed that Gandhi outgrew these prejudices to become firmly anti-racist—a transformation later validated when Nelson Mandela embraced Gandhian principles upon becoming South Africa’s president, even after the African National Congress (formed in 1912) had abandoned non-violence for armed struggle post-1916. Similarly, Guha noted that Gandhi evolved from a traditional patriarch to recognizing the vital political agency of women, particularly during the Dandi March alongside leaders like Sarojini Naidu.
On the contentious subject of caste, Guha argued that pitting Gandhi and Ambedkar purely as adversaries is historically unjust, describing their perspectives as ultimately complementary—what scholar Abhijit Dipke termed the "soul and spine of India," a convergence later echoed by protesting students at Jantar Mantar. While Gandhians unfairly labeled Ambedkar a "British chamcha" and Ambedkar felt Gandhi was moving too slowly, orthodox savarnas attacked Gandhi for moving too fast.
Following the 1932 Poona Pact and Gandhi’s temple-entry campaign, orthodox Brahmins declared untouchability scriptural, called his movement the "death of India," flooded him with abusive letters, and demanded he be declared a non-Hindu because he was neither a Brahmin nor knew Sanskrit—even telling him to "go to a brothel and worship there." Guha summarized their dual approach to eradicating untouchability: while Ambedkar championed *atma samman* (self-respect) for Dalits, Gandhi demanded *atma shuddhi* (self-purification) from the upper castes.
1947–48, the RSS, and Gandhi’s Relevance Today
Turning to the final months of Gandhi’s life between October 1947 and January 1948, Guha cited Delhi Police records detailing the intense hostility Gandhi faced during his peace missions in Noakhali, his fast in Calcutta, and his final days in Delhi. According to Guha, Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) volunteers eagerly awaited Gandhi’s departure from the capital, blaming him for obstructing efforts to drive Muslims out of India—echoing Gandhi’s secretary Pyarelal’s characterization of the RSS as a "communal body with a totalitarian outlook."
Concluding his address, Guha recalled a phone conversation with Gopalkrishna Gandhi following the 1992 Babri Masjid demolition, during which he voiced his fear that while Gandhi might be driven out of India, he would continue to live globally like the Buddha. Rejecting that fate for the country, Guha asserted that preserving Gandhi’s legacy is an existential necessity: "India needs Gandhi to ensure India doesn’t become a Hindu Pakistan."

Comments

TRENDING

China’s Medog dam, India’s Siang project could multiply disaster risks, warns SANDRP

A new report by the advocacy group South Asia Network on Dams, Rivers and People (SANDRP) has warned that China's proposed 60,000 MW Medog hydropower project and India's proposed 11,000 MW Siang Upper Multipurpose Project (SUMP) are being planned in one of the world's most geologically unstable and disaster-prone regions, potentially exposing millions of people downstream to serious risks.

The digital mob: How India’s online manosphere targets women

A sweeping new global report has laid bare how India’s digital landscape has become a toxic breeding ground where male supremacism converges with Hindu nationalist ideologies , fueling severe, algorithmically amplified violence against women—particularly those from minority communities. 

Only 21% of eligible women receive maternity benefits amid digital barriers and debt traps: Survey

Despite being a statutory legal right under the National Food Security Act (NFSA), 2013, maternity entitlements remain out of reach for the vast majority of Indian women, with only 21% of eligible beneficiaries receiving any financial assistance under the Pradhan Mantri Matru Vandana Yojana (PMMVY).