Skip to main content

High GNP growth rate raises serious questions regarding genuine rise in welfare

By Bharat Dogra 

The relevance of GNP or GDP as an indicator of real well-being or welfare has been increasingly questioned. Other things being equal, in any country a period when it chooses to cut down its forests on a massive scale may get recorded in the short run as a period with a higher GDP growth compared to a period when it protected its forests with loving care. A country which chooses to go on a spree of opening gambling dens and casinos may record a higher GDP growth, other things being equal, than a country which has the wisdom to minimize gambling.
In some countries where the rates of GNP growth have been high, serious questions have been raised regarding to what extent this reflects a genuine rise in welfare. In Britain, for instance, the New Economics Foundation has prepared a report on the British economy using more comprehensive indications than GNP which can better assess health, environmental quality and security, housework and other voluntary work. The results of this exercise have been quite striking, making a major break from the conventional measures of economic growth.
This study, which has prepared an index of sustainable welfare for the period approximately of 1950-1990, showed that while GNP increased by 230 per cent since 1950, sustainable economic welfare increased by only 3%. What is even more significant is that sustainable economic welfare in Britain actually declined at quite a fast pace after 1974. During the fifteen year period 1975-1990, GNP rose by a third but sustainable economic welfare fell by about 50 per cent.
A different type of data was provided by researchers from the British Social Science Research Council (SSRC) during the early 1970s. They questioned a sample of 1500 people thrice within five years, about the changes in the quality of life. The people who were interviewed almost unanimously said that their level of consumption had gone up yet the quality of life had gone down during the last five years. What is more, they said that they expected this trend of consumption going up and quality of life going down to continue during the next five years.
A study by Herman Daly and John Cobb titled ‘For the Common Good’ supports this view in the context of the USA. This study published in 1990, shows that economic welfare in the USA rose to a peak in 1969, remained on a plateau for eleven years, then fell during 1980 to 1986 even though GNP continued to increase.
Economist Havelock R. Brewster wrote during the 1990s about the experience of developed countries, “Over the last ten years these countries have created an additional $ 6000 billion of national product. But few would be genuinely persuaded that the welfare of people in their societies has improved. Most likely, it has diminished - with the growth of unemployment and totally destitute people, the deterioration and delay in the provision of health services, alienation of the young and the old, diminishing participation in decision making, ever-increasing obesity, urban decay and chaos, the deterioration of transportation and other public utilities and endemic pollution.”
To the extent that GNP rise is accompanied by such clear gains as increase in life expectancy, these should be recognized but even here we must ask whether there is genuine improvement of overall health. In Britain, for instance, General Household Surveys in 1972 and 1988 revealed a 50% increase in ‘long standing illness’ and a 75% increase in acute illness during the preceding two weeks. In the same country during 1960-90 hospital admission for children suffering from asthma went up by ten times. All this happened at a time of recorded significant rise in GNP. Walter Yellowlees, a highly experienced doctor of this country said in a paper read to the Royal College of General Practitioners about health advancement in several rich countries: “I believe it is true to say that is those countries which have achieved unparalleled advance in technological skill in medicine and in what is called standard of living, we are witnessing the decay of man - the decay of his teeth, his arteries, his bowels and his joints on a colossal and unprecedented scale.” Recent increases in mental health problems in several rich countries, among adult members of society but even more among children and adolescents, have been so extreme that in 2021 leading child health organizations in the USA called for declaring an emergency related to child and adolescent mental health--all this in countries recording some of the highest GNP in world.
However the more important point is how and where we can find significantly better indicators than GNP. Some of the previous attempts in this direction are also in need of further updating and improvements keeping in view the increasing threat from climate change and other environmental problems. The increasing environmental burden means that there is lesser scope now than ever before for all wasteful and harmful consumption and production as the environmental space within which all consumption and production should take place now is very limited.
Hence the focus should now be on the extent to which the basic needs of all people are being met in a satisfactory and sustainable way within the limits of an environmental space (one important aspect of which is within the limits of tolerable or permissible GHG emissions), the environmental space being calculated in terms of what is compatible with avoiding a survival crisis as the basic life nurturing conditions of earth have to be protected as the highest priority. This principle should not be allowed to be distorted by such dubious concepts and practices as buying carbon credits.
So a much better indicator is the satisfactory achievement of basic needs for all plus to extent to which environment space is not transcended. Further we have to consider if any country is shifting its environmental burden on other countries by shifting its polluting industries or waste products elsewhere. In mathematical terms all this will involve positive as well as negative marking, with a net value being calculated.
An additional aspect to be considered consists of social relationships, values for which can be calculated on the basis of various indicators of social integration and harmony. Lastly, indicators of equality of wealth and income as well as gender equality can be added to present a more comprehensive indicator. The extent to which a country is exploitative of other countries should get negative marking, with broad categories being decided for this, for instance a country in the category of being extremely exploitative getting 5 negative marks, while a country in the category of being moderately exploitative gets 3 negative marks, and so on.
While no indicator can be complete in itself, these suggestions can lead to finding a better indicator than the ones existing at present, either in terms of GNP or its slight improvements.
---
The writer is Honorary Convener, Campaign to Save Earth Now. His recent books include ‘Planet in Peril', ‘Man over Machine' and ‘A Day in 2071’

Comments

TRENDING

Sengol imbroglio suggests reason why Modi, BJP don't respect modern Indian history

By Vidya Bhushan Rawat*  The new parliament building opened on February 28. It looks it is not the Parliament but part of #Pratinidhisabhas ' started by earstwhile #princelystates in India. The #BJP for long has been acting as if India is a #Kingdom and Modi ji the new #King of India. Even at the coronations of Kings, you find a large number of people, and dignitaries but look at the opening ceremony we have only one face as if he build everything. Is it the dream of a republic.

Abrogation of Art 370: Increasing alienation, relentless repression, simmering conflict

One year after the abrogation by the Central Government of Art. 370 in Kashmir, what is the situation in the Valley. Have the promises of peace, normalcy and development been realised? What is the current status in the Valley? Here is a detailed note by the People’s Union for Civil Liberties , “Jammu & Kashmir: One Year after Abrogation of Art. 370: Increasing Alienation, Relentless Repression, Simmering Conflict”:

Cave of Spleen - a feminist perspective: Status of women in early 18th century England

The Cave of Spleen: Aubrey Beardsley's illustration for Pope's “The Rape of the Lock” By Pragya Ranjan  "The Rape of the Lock" by Alexander Pope published in 1712 is a mock-heroic narrative which satirically glorifies trivial incident of cutting of locks of protagonist Belinda. This poem was written in the Augustan Era (1660-1784) which is marked by the period of scientific reason and rationality, whose effect can be seen on the writers of those times. This timeline is particularly important to analyse the episode of the Cave of Spleen.

Release of dabang neta: Rule of law can't be allowed to be slave to political rhetoric

By Vidya Bhushan Rawat*  When we look to politicians for solutions and politics as the 'final solution' for every evil then we are disappointed most of the time. In politics, we knowingly or unknowingly become part of the propaganda tool of the ruling elite which exists everywhere across different castes. We often provide issues and talk about them in binaries which suit our elites. The minorities among the marginalised who have no political space and representation rarely get heard by these majoritarian parties whose agenda remain power communities. Every political party in today's time is following the 'successful' formula of 'democracy' which is keeping the 'powerful' 'jaatis' with them leaving aside the marginalised one. The BJP started this but yes they cobbled together all other communities too through a diverse narrative.

Discussion on making school education meaningful to vulnerable communities

ActionAid note on workshop to boost National Curriculum Framework operations: *** Leading educationists and activists striving to make education meaningful to vulnerable communities gathered in Delhi to discuss the National Curriculum Framework for School Education (NCFSE). Acting in response to the call of the NCF Steering Committee appointed by the Ministry of Education, Government of India, ActionAid Association had organised the meeting to gather feedback on the draft NCFSE. This is part of ActionAid Association’s commitment to promote inclusive and gender-responsive education. The two-day national workshop titled ‘NCF Perspectives: Seeking Feedback on National Curriculum Framework (NCF)’ on May 30 and 31, 2023, was held at India International Centre, New Delhi. The workshop aimed to ensure a structured approach to gathering feedback from key stakeholders and enhancing their active participation in shaping the response sought by the Government of India. Stakeholders representing e

Why are 17 Indian cos, including Sterlite, blacklisted by Norway bank

By Venkatesh Nayak* Readers may recall the gory incidents that took place at Thoothukudi (Tuticorin) in Tamil Nadu in the southern part of India on 22 May, 2018. Thirteen protesters died on the spot when the police opened fire to disperse an assemblage of thousands of local residents and representatives of civil society groups. They were protesting against the adverse environmental impact of the industrial operations of Sterlite Copper which runs a copper smelter plant in the area. Accusations against the company have ranged from polluting local water resources to plans for expanding the installed capacity of the plant without the necessary environmental clearances. A ground report published in The Wire recently, mentions the decision taken by Norges Bank a few years ago to not invest funds from Norway’s Government Pension Fund Global (GPFG) in Sterlite “due to an unacceptable risk of complicity in current and future severe environmental damage and systematic human rights violations

J&K RTI activist denied opportunity to address audience, bring forward critical issues

Statement by Er. Irfan Banka, Founder of J&K RTI Foundation and convener of the Nalae Ferozpora Bachav Movement, regarding the incident of official misconduct during the My Town My Pride Jan Abhiyan Program and communication to Raj Bhavan: *** Er. Irfan Banka, a prominent RTI Activist and advocate, has come forward to address an incident of misconduct that occurred during the My Town My Pride Jan Abhiyan Program held at Mugam Town Hall in  Budgam. Additionally, Er. Irfan Banka has communicated the matter to Raj Bhavan, seeking appropriate action. During the event, Er. Irfan Banka was denied the opportunity to address the audience and bring forward critical issues concerning the people and services in the community, including waste management, traffic management, and the achievement of sustainable development goals. The incident involved the Additional Registrar Co-operative Kashmir, who not only prevented Er. Irfan Banka from speaking but also subjected him to public humiliation. E

Danger ahead: Smartphones making teens sexually smart, but mentally disturbed

By Harasankar Adhikari  We live in a digitally globalised society. Bombarded consumerism and imitation of foreign cultures and practises reshape our everyday lives. Life choices and lifestyles are the driving forces of modernity at present. People of almost all ages are within this realm and rhythm of consumerism for happiness.

Big challenge for environment movement: How to link with justice, peace movements?

By Bharat Dogra  The biggest hope for resolving life-threatening environmental problems of our planet increasingly rests now not with the world-level political leadership, which has failed miserably in many critical contexts, but instead with those highly committed environmental activists who have many significant achievements to their credit despite working in the middle of many difficulties. Alas, even they too are often grim today instead of being enthused because of the rather overwhelming conditions of world which force environment protection to go two steps backward even when the activists and movements achieve the difficult task of moving one step ahead.

Worship practice of Hindu religion in official functions should be considered appropriate

By NS Venkataraman* The new Indian parliament building was inaugurated with much fanfare, pomp and show by Prime Minister Modi befitting the occasion. While the magnificent building with several technological features was built in just over two years , the style and structure of the building has been acclaimed by millions of people who saw the inaugural programme. Those who saw this programme in person or in visual media could not miss the fact that the installation of Sengol ( Sceptre) was the hall mark of this elegant programme . In India, historically, Sengol is considered to be the symbol of justice and good governance.