Skip to main content

Vulnerability pushes non-working members of poor Gujarat households towards fringe

By Rajiv Shah 
Bardoligam, Chikhligam, Gandevigam and Adulgam are four villages situated on the fringe of the Golden Corridor between Mumbai and Ahmedabad, one of India’s most industrially developed zone. Yet, it is here that majority of poor, especially the most vulnerable sections among them, fail to get the social benefits they are entitled to, says senior Amsterdam-based scholar Jan Breman.
In his recent study, “The Practice of Poor Relief in Rural South Gujarat”, Breman, emeritus professor of sociology, Amsterdam Institute for Science Research (AISSR), University of Amsterdam, has suggested that, following Gharib Kalyan melas in the recent past, there has been a big talk about “a slow but steady decrease in poverty due to an accelerated pace of overall economic growth, is said to have marginally or even significantly reduced the vulnerability of people who have no other means of livelihood than their labour power.” However, the senior scholar, basing his study on four South Gujarat villages, has stated their destitution has remained “understated in literature”, and though the state had initiated attempts to redress the vulnerability of these, this has actually not happened.
The study is based on fieldwork by collecting data on poverty-ridden households which wholly or partially lack the labour power required to make a living — the old aged, single women and the physically or mentally handicapped of all ages, is based. The villages studied are Bardoligam in the Surat district, Chikhligam in Navsari district, Gandevigam in the Navsari district and Atulgam in the Valsad district. Situated on the fringe of what is known as the golden corridor, which is the hub of industrial-urban zone between Mumbai and Ahmedabad, the study has found that out of the 101 households surveyed, as many as 152 individuals “should have been recipients of social benefits because of old age, widowhood or physical /mental disability”.
However, he says, “Out of this total only 29 were granted such benefits – 22 an old age pension, six a widowhood allowance and one an allowance as a handicapped youngster.” He insists, “Exclusion from statutory benefits more often than not is all the more serious. It basically means that the working poor are supposed to take care of those who do not belong to households in which other members are earning an income. They have to provide for the livelihood of the non-working poor. Worse off are elderly men and women as well as widows who run their own households and, because of their inability to be gainfully employed, are badly in need of outside support for minimum requirements.“
Breman finds “identifying the categories of vulnerability is highly uneven”. According to him, “Although most men and women of old age do not get a pension, a fair share of them (22 out of 52) have managed to find access to this provision. But again, their inclusion shows an enormous variation even between localities situated at a short distance from each other.” Indicating that the disproportionate distribution is particularly skewed spread in Chikhligam, he says, during interviews, “many of them said to have been completely unaware about the existence of these benefits even if a neighbouring household had found access to them. Neither did they make any effort to come to know whether they would qualify.”
Pointing towards how the poor are neglected, Breman says, “The state does not come to the clients but the clients have to approach the state.” He adds, “A lot of paperwork is required beyond the reach of the people.” They are “unable to fill up forms, collect certificates and other documents testifying to their credentials – below poverty line or BPL card, photograph, voters’ card, birth/death certificate, a school diploma, receipt for payment of house tax or electricity bill and the most puzzling requirement of all, authenticated proof of their monthly or annual income, evidence of their identity which they require when handing in their application.”
The poor also have to face other types of hurdle – for instance, time and again they are made to make costly trips to the sub-district or district headquarters with sets of papers painstakingly brought together. These have to be “submitted but to no avail. Sometimes hurdles are also found too difficult to cross. For instance, how can a widow show proof that her annual earnings are less than Rs. 2,400 or below Rs 4,500 for the whole household of which she happens to be part and parcel? Her saying so will have to be put in writing in an affidavit signed by her and accepted by an official willing to be persuaded that her statement is correct. But this leniency has to be bought for a couple hundred rupees, a lot of money as well as an investment with a high risk of non-delivery”.
Pointing out that “the high percentage of non-inclusion cannot be attributed mainly to the failure of the non-working poor to find access to the social welfare schemes”, Breman says, “The state is to be blamed for not reaching out to alleviate the plight of its poorest clientele.” For instance, on becoming widowed a woman is entitled to a one-time allowance of Rs 10,000 immediately after the demise of their husband. The application has to be “processed at the sub-district level with the mamlatdar as the authorising agent. Forms for an old age pension allotted to men and women from the age of 60 years onwards (of monthly Rs 200 between 60-65 years, increased to Rs 400 above 65 years) have to be submitted to officials at the district collectorate with the prant officer, who is second in command to the collector, as the sanctioning authority.”


Breman says, “The Social Defence Department at the district level handles applications for a regular widow allowance amounting to Rs 500 per month with a supplement for a child of Rs 80 up to a maximum of two children. The same agency is in charge of processing applications submitted by the severely handicapped. Deserving cases are entitled to a monthly allowance of Rs 200 for youngsters less than 17 years of age, increased to Rs. 400 for the age bracket between 18-64 years. Between the various administrative echelons and also between the various departments involved at either the district or subdistrict level there is a lack of coordination and communication which is counterproductive to the interests of the clientele.”
He points out, “Adding to the confusion created in and by the government apparatus is that the chain of officials handling the files are not instructed to report back on the action taken. The talati, who is in charge of the village administration, has no idea who is beneficiaries of social provisions and neither does he receive information on applications submitted, pending or rejected. Many government officials are not familiar with the range of social provisions made available. The talatis of both Gandevigam and Chikhligam had only a faint notion of the differential pensions for the old age, the first one of Rs 200 paid solely by the Gujarat government for the elderly from 60 to 65 years and the second one for men and women above 65 of Rs 400 out of a fund to which both the Gujarat government and the Central government each contribute Rs 200 monthly.”
Breman believes that in view of the arbitrary and biased way in which the below poverty line (BPL) survey was carried out, and subsequently adjusted downwards for political reason, “it should come as no surprise that there are many cases of vulnerability which escape formal registration. Having failed to become classified as poor such people are incorrectly exempted from state provided social benefits.” The result is that “of the 152 potential beneficiaries only 29 had been granted the allowance to which they are entitled.” A random sample survey of BPL households in the four villages of under survey suggested the predicament of the non-working poor and how they suffer.
Apart from “incorrect exclusion” from the BPL, Breman says, the sample suggested another problem – “inclusion for the wrong reasons”: “A striking example is an elderly Anavil woman in Gandevigam who receives a widow’s allowance. Although certainly not well endowed, her condition is not so bad that she can be considered a fitting case for state benevolence. Her name is not included in the BPL list, but belonging to a family of landowners she also receives a monthly stipend from the fund that the dominant caste has set up for needy members. In other words, there are other criteria for deciding on applications than the ones formally put on record.”
In his concluding remarks, Breman says, “Self-reliance cannot be the organizing principle for providing social security and protection at the bottom of the rural economy when the working poor barely succeed to take care of their own basic needs let alone that they can be held accountable for looking after the non-working segment of the old aged, single females and handicapped in their midst. To at least alleviate the misery in which both the non-working and working poor are entrapped in South Gujarat, the state has to be more forthcoming and forceful in extending social benefits as well in the generation of public employment than it has been so far.

Comments

TRENDING

Global Ambedkarites in deep shock over killing of Buddhist Ambedkarite youth in Nanded

Joint  Ambedkar International Mission and Ambedkar Association of North America statement on killing of an Ambedkarite Buddhist youth for celebrating Dr Ambedkar Jayanti (birth anniversary) in his village on 1st June 2023 in Bondhar Haveli village, Nanded, Maharashtra: *** Every single public event hosted by any social or political organization in Maharashtra is not completed without citing Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar and yet an Ambedkarite Buddhist youth, Akshay Bhalerao was brutally murdered for celebrating Dr Ambedkar Jayanti in the village Bondhar, Nanded, Maharashtra by dominant caste goons. Caste Atrocities are common in such villages where the Scheduled Castes and Buddhists are daily humiliated, mocked, or abused with caste slurs and women subjected to sexual violence. 

How this top Maoist leader couldn't extricate completely from the Left adventurist line

By Harsh Thakor  On the 31st of May Katakam Sudarshan, known as Comrade Anand, breathed his last, at the age of 69. Anand was a member of the Politburo of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of India (Maoists) and an important leader of the revolutionary movement of India.

Discussion on making school education meaningful to vulnerable communities

ActionAid note on workshop to boost National Curriculum Framework operations: *** Leading educationists and activists striving to make education meaningful to vulnerable communities gathered in Delhi to discuss the National Curriculum Framework for School Education (NCFSE). Acting in response to the call of the NCF Steering Committee appointed by the Ministry of Education, Government of India, ActionAid Association had organised the meeting to gather feedback on the draft NCFSE. This is part of ActionAid Association’s commitment to promote inclusive and gender-responsive education. The two-day national workshop titled ‘NCF Perspectives: Seeking Feedback on National Curriculum Framework (NCF)’ on May 30 and 31, 2023, was held at India International Centre, New Delhi. The workshop aimed to ensure a structured approach to gathering feedback from key stakeholders and enhancing their active participation in shaping the response sought by the Government of India. Stakeholders representing e

Abrogation of Art 370: Increasing alienation, relentless repression, simmering conflict

One year after the abrogation by the Central Government of Art. 370 in Kashmir, what is the situation in the Valley. Have the promises of peace, normalcy and development been realised? What is the current status in the Valley? Here is a detailed note by the People’s Union for Civil Liberties , “Jammu & Kashmir: One Year after Abrogation of Art. 370: Increasing Alienation, Relentless Repression, Simmering Conflict”:

Release of dabang neta: Rule of law can't be allowed to be slave to political rhetoric

By Vidya Bhushan Rawat*  When we look to politicians for solutions and politics as the 'final solution' for every evil then we are disappointed most of the time. In politics, we knowingly or unknowingly become part of the propaganda tool of the ruling elite which exists everywhere across different castes. We often provide issues and talk about them in binaries which suit our elites. The minorities among the marginalised who have no political space and representation rarely get heard by these majoritarian parties whose agenda remain power communities. Every political party in today's time is following the 'successful' formula of 'democracy' which is keeping the 'powerful' 'jaatis' with them leaving aside the marginalised one. The BJP started this but yes they cobbled together all other communities too through a diverse narrative.

J&K RTI activist denied opportunity to address audience, bring forward critical issues

Statement by Er. Irfan Banka, Founder of J&K RTI Foundation and convener of the Nalae Ferozpora Bachav Movement, regarding the incident of official misconduct during the My Town My Pride Jan Abhiyan Program and communication to Raj Bhavan: *** Er. Irfan Banka, a prominent RTI Activist and advocate, has come forward to address an incident of misconduct that occurred during the My Town My Pride Jan Abhiyan Program held at Mugam Town Hall in  Budgam. Additionally, Er. Irfan Banka has communicated the matter to Raj Bhavan, seeking appropriate action. During the event, Er. Irfan Banka was denied the opportunity to address the audience and bring forward critical issues concerning the people and services in the community, including waste management, traffic management, and the achievement of sustainable development goals. The incident involved the Additional Registrar Co-operative Kashmir, who not only prevented Er. Irfan Banka from speaking but also subjected him to public humiliation. E

Why are 17 Indian cos, including Sterlite, blacklisted by Norway bank

By Venkatesh Nayak* Readers may recall the gory incidents that took place at Thoothukudi (Tuticorin) in Tamil Nadu in the southern part of India on 22 May, 2018. Thirteen protesters died on the spot when the police opened fire to disperse an assemblage of thousands of local residents and representatives of civil society groups. They were protesting against the adverse environmental impact of the industrial operations of Sterlite Copper which runs a copper smelter plant in the area. Accusations against the company have ranged from polluting local water resources to plans for expanding the installed capacity of the plant without the necessary environmental clearances. A ground report published in The Wire recently, mentions the decision taken by Norges Bank a few years ago to not invest funds from Norway’s Government Pension Fund Global (GPFG) in Sterlite “due to an unacceptable risk of complicity in current and future severe environmental damage and systematic human rights violations

Sengol imbroglio suggests reason why Modi, BJP don't respect modern Indian history

By Vidya Bhushan Rawat*  The new parliament building opened on February 28. It looks it is not the Parliament but part of #Pratinidhisabhas ' started by earstwhile #princelystates in India. The #BJP for long has been acting as if India is a #Kingdom and Modi ji the new #King of India. Even at the coronations of Kings, you find a large number of people, and dignitaries but look at the opening ceremony we have only one face as if he build everything. Is it the dream of a republic.

Danger ahead: Smartphones making teens sexually smart, but mentally disturbed

By Harasankar Adhikari  We live in a digitally globalised society. Bombarded consumerism and imitation of foreign cultures and practises reshape our everyday lives. Life choices and lifestyles are the driving forces of modernity at present. People of almost all ages are within this realm and rhythm of consumerism for happiness.

Cave of Spleen - a feminist perspective: Status of women in early 18th century England

The Cave of Spleen: Aubrey Beardsley's illustration for Pope's “The Rape of the Lock” By Pragya Ranjan  "The Rape of the Lock" by Alexander Pope published in 1712 is a mock-heroic narrative which satirically glorifies trivial incident of cutting of locks of protagonist Belinda. This poem was written in the Augustan Era (1660-1784) which is marked by the period of scientific reason and rationality, whose effect can be seen on the writers of those times. This timeline is particularly important to analyse the episode of the Cave of Spleen.