Skip to main content

‘Supplementary at best': Ex-Union secretary rejects sociologist’s alternatives to Kalpasar

In a  sharp rejoinder over the proposed Kalpasar reservoir project in the Gulf of Khambhat, with former Government of India Secretary Babubhai Navalawala has dismissed the alternatives floated by veteran sociologist Prof. Vidyut Joshi as mere “supplements” rather than substitutes for the mega project.
In the rejoinder to Prof. Joshi’s recent column Samudra Manthan in Gujarati daily Sandesh (see news item here), Navalawala has argued that the scientific options suggested by the sociologist cannot replace Kalpasar. 
Quoting from the rejoinder, Navalawala states: “These scientific options should not be considered as substitutes or replacements for the proposed Kalpasar Project. Rather, they can only be treated as supplements to it.”
Citing data from an attached concept note on Kalpasar, Navalawala points out that the total water storage from all the proposed alternative measures put together would amount to “at most about 15 percent of the storage of the proposed Kalpasar reservoir, which is approximately 13,000 million cubic metres.” The concept note, which lists over 30 studies already carried out by expert bodies including IIT Roorkee, NIOT, NIO Goa, CSIR-CSMCRI and NEERI, underscores the massive scale of the planned reservoir. 
Navalawala also raised legal and practical hurdles. “Among the rivers for which you have proposed alternatives, particularly the Mahi river, one cannot ignore the existing interstate water dispute,” he writes. 
He further notes that most river-specific alternatives would involve land submergence and rehabilitation issues, including forest land, and that “the very concerns you have highlighted as a sociologist about displacement would apply to these scattered alternatives, perhaps even more severely.”
According to the concept note attached with the rejoinder – a detailed compilation of investigations carried out, ongoing, and envisaged for Kalpasar – several studies are already in progress, including geotechnical investigations along the dam alignment, water quality monitoring, and hydraulic model studies by the Central Water and Power Research Station (CWPRS). The note also lists planned studies on irrigation canals, pumping stations, and wind-solar power plants.
While acknowledging that work on feasible scientific alternatives should begin even before Kalpasar becomes a ground reality, Navalawala stressed that they must be pursued in parallel, not as a replacement. 
“They must be seen as complementary to Kalpasar,” he concluded. The exchange highlights a deepening debate over one of Gujarat’s most ambitious and contentious water infrastructure projects.

Comments

TRENDING

Proposed UPI merchant charges risk driving small vendors back to cash, warns new ISB study

  A new study by the Indian School of Business (ISB) warns that the proposed Merchant Discount Rate (MDR) framework for UPI transactions could inadvertently reverse digital payment adoption among India’s street vendors, pushing them back toward cash-based transactions and threatening recent gains in financial inclusion.

Audiences want human stories: 2026 Commercial Filmmaking Trend Report

  Sister comp anies  Filmsupply and Musicbed have released their  2026 Commercial Filmmaking Trend Report,  a comprehensive forecast arguing that "the future of commercial filmmaking is intentional and human." Filmsupply is a premium footage licensing agency, representing award-winning filmmakers, providing authentic, cinematic stock footage for use in films, TV, and advertising, while Musicbed is a music licensing platform for filmmakers, brands, and agencies. T he films analysed are confined to North America and Europe. 

India among targets as China-linked hackers 'exploit' VPNs, firewalls

Cyberattackers grew faster and harder to detect in 2025, increasingly slipping through trusted systems rather than breaking in with obvious malware, claims U.S.-based  cybersecurity technology company CrowdStrike's 2026 Global Threat Report . The report says adversaries "grew more evasive than ever before," exploiting trust in supply chain partners, legitimate software, internal systems and employees. CrowdStrike now tracks 281 adversaries after naming 24 new ones in 2025, plus 150 activity clusters and emerging threat groups.